(1)
NASER BIN ABU BAKR YAFAI .....Appellant Vs.
THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ANOTHER .....Respondent D.D
20/10/2021
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
NIA Act – Continuation of Investigation – Once the Central government directed the NIA to take over the investigation under Section 6(4) of the NIA Act, the ATS Nanded had a duty to continue the investigation until the NIA actually took over – The investigation by ATS Nanded and filing of the charge-sheet were valid under Section 6(7) of the NIA Act [Paras 19-23].
Jurisdiction...
(2)
MILKHI RAM .....Appellant Vs.
HIMACHAL PRADESH STATE ELECTRICITY BOARD .....Respondent D.D
08/10/2021
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Industrial Disputes Act – Jurisdiction – Civil court lacks jurisdiction to entertain a suit structured on the provisions of the Industrial Disputes Act – Plaintiff’s claim based on ID Act must be adjudicated by appropriate forums under the ID Act – High Court rightly set aside lower courts’ judgments favoring the plaintiff – Decree by civil court declared ...
(3)
DR. YASHWANTRAO BHASKARRAO DESHMUKH .....Appellant Vs.
RAGHUNATH KISAN SAINDANE .....Respondent D.D
08/10/2021
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Specific Performance – Non-service of Notice – Appeal against High Court’s rejection of condonation of delay due to non-service of notice following change of address – Appellant produced documents proving address change – High Court did not conduct proper inquiry or make findings disbelieving the appellant’s explanation – High Court erred in dismissing app...
(4)
M/S GIMPEX PRIVATE LIMITED .....Appellant Vs.
MANOJ GOEL .....Respondent D.D
08/10/2021
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Negotiable Instruments Act – Section 138 – Quashing of Complaint – High Court erred in quashing proceedings under Section 138 based on pending suit challenging compromise deed – Compliance with Section 138 NI Act constitutes an offence upon dishonour of cheques – Question of liability to be determined at trial – Quashing set aside, complaints reinstated [Paras 1...
(5)
NASIB SINGH .....Appellant Vs.
THE STATE OF PUNJAB AND ANOTHER .....Respondent D.D
08/10/2021
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Criminal Law – Non-Joinder of Trials – The High Court's direction for retrial by combining FIRs for gang rape and abetment of suicide due to perceived prejudice from separate trials – Prosecution case involved gang rape resulting in the prosecutrix's suicide – High Court remitted conviction and acquittal orders for retrial under Section 223 CrPC – Separate tri...
(6)
PRASHANT SINGH RAJPUT .....Appellant Vs.
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH AND ANOTHER .....Respondent D.D
08/10/2021
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Anticipatory Bail – Cancellation – High Court granted anticipatory bail ignoring material aspects such as the nature and gravity of the offence and the specific allegations against the accused – Deficiencies in the investigation highlighted by JMFC and trial court, including failure to consider eyewitness statements, reliance on selective CCTV footage, and lack of fingerprint ana...
(7)
SRI SRINIVAS K GOUDA .....Appellant Vs.
KARNATAKA INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL SCIENCES AND OTHERS .....Respondent D.D
08/10/2021
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Service Law – Selection Process – High Court set aside the appointment of the appellant to the post of Junior Lab Technician on grounds of arbitrariness in marks allocation for experience and interview – Selection Committee's criteria for allocating marks after advertisement found to change "rules of the game" – Division Bench of the High Court erred in examin...
(8)
MANOJ MISHRA @ CHHOTKAU .....Appellant Vs.
THE STATE OF UTTAR PRADESH .....Respondent D.D
08/10/2021
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Penal Code – Gang Rape – Conviction – Conviction under Section 376D IPC questioned – Evidence of the prosecutrix indicates repeated rape by the appellant over four months – No conclusive evidence of common intention or aiding by co-accused to establish gang rape – Conviction under Section 376D IPC modified to Section 376 IPC [Paras 9-12].
Evidentiary Value &n...
(9)
ESTATE OFFICER .....Appellant Vs.
COLONEL H.V. MANKOTIA (RETIRED) .....Respondent D.D
07/10/2021
SUPREME COURT OF INDIA
Lok Adalat – Jurisdiction and Authority – Lok Adalat has jurisdiction only to determine and arrive at a compromise or settlement between the parties to a dispute – If no compromise or settlement is reached, the Lok Adalat must return the case to the referring court – Lok Adalat has no jurisdiction to decide the matter on merits in the absence of a settlement – Impugne...