Criminal Law – Conviction under Section 411 IPC – Theft Not Proved – Conviction Unsustainable – Appellant was convicted under Section 411 IPC for allegedly receiving stolen property after helping co-accused dispose of a dead body – However, both appellant and co-accused had been acquitted under Section 379 IPC for theft – Supreme Court held that conviction under...
Criminal Law – Obstruction of Public Servant – Quashing of FIR – SHO allegedly obstructed a process server from serving court summons/warrants – Process server was allegedly humiliated, detained, and punished within the police station – Administrative Civil Judge filed a complaint under Section 195 Cr.P.C. – Chief Metropolitan Magistrate erroneously directed pol...
Criminal Law – Bail in Corruption and Conspiracy Case – Delay in Trial and Right to Liberty – Bail Granted - The appellant was incarcerated for nearly three years under charges of corruption and forgery under IPC and PC Act – Investigation completed, charge sheet filed, but charges not framed – Held: Continuing incarceration without framing of charges or examining wit...
Criminal Law - Bail – Sections 302, 307, 333, 353 of the IPC - Non-Reasoned Order – High Court’s Grant of Bail Without Recording Reasons – Set Aside – The respondent-accused was granted bail by the High Court in a serious offence involving the murder of a project coordinator and his bodyguard – Supreme Court found that the High Court failed to assign any reasons...
Criminal Law - Abetment of Suicide – High Court Quashing of FIR – No Prima Facie Case Made – Dismissal of Appeal – The appellant challenged the High Court’s decision quashing the FIR registered against officials and administrators of Dadra and Nagar Haveli who were named in the suicide note of a seven-time Member of Parliament – The Supreme Court held that the a...
Criminal Law – Conviction for Sexual Offences – Testimony of Victim Not Reliable – Acquittal Ordered – Appellants convicted for offences under Sections 452/354/323/34 IPC for allegedly assaulting and molesting a woman – Trial Court acquitted them under Section 376(D) IPC – High Court found the victim’s testimony riddled with material improvements, inconsis...
Criminal Law - Murder – Circumstantial Evidence – Conviction Upheld – Appeal Dismissed – Appellants convicted under Sections 302, 120B IPC for murdering railway employee Hanuman Rai in his quarter—Prosecution relied entirely on circumstantial evidence: CCTV footage placing accused near crime scene, CDR/SDR data showing last call from accused Mobarak to victim minutes ...
Criminal Law – Discharge under Section 227 CrPC – Judicial Application of Mind Lacking – Matter Remanded – Petitioner challenged the Sessions Court’s dismissal of his discharge petition without proper reasoning – Court held that prior rejection of a revision challenging cognizance under Section 190 CrPC does not bar a discharge application under Section 227, as ...
Bail Appeal – Section 14-A(2) SC/ST Act – Appeal Allowed – The appellant challenged rejection of his bail applications in offences under IPC including Section 376, 376D and SC/ST Act – Victim’s statement under Sections 180 and 183 BNSS contained contradictions; no supporting medical evidence; trial yet to commence – Court found that essential ingredients of SC/S...
Criminal Law – Quashing of FIR - POCSO Act – Gender Neutrality – Sections 3, 4, 5, 6 POCSO – Held Gender Neutral – The Court held that the POCSO Act, as evident from its objects and reasons (2012 and 2019 amendments), is intended to protect all children (male or female) below 18 years from sexual offences – Section 2(2) POCSO read with Section 8 IPC clarifies th...