Criminal Law – Bail – Age Discrepancy of Victim – Petitioner accused of abducting and marrying minor girl under false documents – Conflicting DOBs: 01.01.2007 (from NIOS) and 19.04.2008 (school record) – Held: Discrepancy in age creates reasonable doubt – In view of Mahadeo v. State of Maharashtra and State of MP v. Anoop Singh, court must rely on school DOB unl...
Dowry Death – Sentence under Section 304-B IPC – Reduction of Life Imprisonment – Husband Convicted – Sentencing Principles Applied – Appellant-husband convicted under Section 304-B IPC and sentenced to life imprisonment by Trial Court – Appellate Court held that life imprisonment is not mandatory under Section 304-B IPC and sentence must be proportionate to cul...
Criminal Law – Appeal Against Acquittal – Dishonour of Cheque – Maintainability – Applicant filed for leave to appeal under Section 378(4) CrPC against acquittal in complaint under Section 138 of N.I. Act – Held: In view of the Supreme Court decision in M/s. Celestium Financial v. A. Gnanasekaran, complainant in a cheque dishonour case is a "victim" under Se...
Domestic Violence – Quasi-Criminal Proceedings – Bailable Warrants – Issuance of bailable warrants by the Magistrate in proceedings under the D.V. Act deprecated – Held: Proceedings under the D.V. Act are quasi-criminal in nature and do not attract penal consequences unless there is a breach of protection order – Magistrate unjustified in issuing bailable warrants in ...
NDPS Act – Bail – Sections 8, 21, 29 NDPS Act - Commercial Quantity – Procedural Lapses – Bail Granted – Petitioner arrested on 21.04.2023 for alleged possession of 50 bottles of Myberry (Codeine Phosphate) – Co-accused arrested based on petitioner's disclosure – Final report filed on 17.07.2023 – Trial delayed with less than half of 21 witnesses...
Criminal Law – Culpable Homicide – Section 304A IPC – Death by Alleged Stone Pelting – Appellant convicted by Trial Court for causing death through rash and negligent act – On appeal, High Court finds that key witnesses including P.W.3 (complainant), P.W.4 and P.W.6 (injured) admitted inability to identify assailants due to darkness – No torchlight allegedly use...
Extradition Law – Dual Criminality – India-Canada Treaty – Prima Facie Satisfaction for Magisterial Inquiry – Validity of MEA’s Decision – Petitioner challenged MEA’s direction under Section 5 of Extradition Act initiating magisterial inquiry into Canadian extradition request for offence under Section 320.16(3) of Canadian Criminal Code – Held: The a...
Negotiable Instruments Act – Section 138 – Dishonour of Cheques – Legally Enforceable Debt – Lease Agreement – The appellant issued four post-dated cheques amounting to ₹9,00,000/- as security deposit refund under a lease agreement – Upon dishonour, the respondent filed criminal complaints – The Trial Court convicted the appellant but awarded only ₹3,0...
Cheque Dishonour – Presumption of Legally Enforceable Debt – Sections 118 & 139 of the Negotiable Instruments Act – Presumption Operated - The accused admitted the signature on the cheque but claimed the cheque was lost – The intimation of loss was found to be doubtful as it was lodged one year after the alleged loss – The accused failed to rebut the statutory pre...
NI Act, S.138(b) — Notice must demand the very cheque amount — Any variance renders notice invalid — Typographical error no defence — Complaint rightly quashed — Appeals dismissed
Negotiable Instruments — Section 138(b) — Meaning of “said amount of money” — Notice must demand the cheque amount and none other — Demand for a figure...