Criminal Law – Kidnapping for Ransom and Murder – Conviction based on circumstantial and eyewitness evidence – Kidnapping of a 16-year-old schoolboy for ransom of ₹50 lakhs – Victim found murdered by administering chloroform and pentazocine (Fortwin) overdose – Recoveries made at instance of accused – Held: Chain of circumstances complete and consistent only w...
Criminal Law – Rape – Conviction based on sole testimony of prosecutrix – Corroboration not a rule of law – Victim’s evidence found trustworthy and consistent with medical and circumstantial evidence – Minor inconsistencies or absence of injuries not fatal – Absence of chemical examination of clothes or injuries cannot undermine credible testimony – ...
Criminal Law – Rash and Negligent Driving – Appeal Against Acquittal – Respondent accused of driving a tanker rashly and hitting a cyclist who died on the spot – Eyewitness accounts (PW5 and PW6) found inconsistent, contradictory, and uncorroborated by physical evidence – No mechanical inspection of the cycle conducted – Tanker inspection showed no fresh damage ...
Criminal Law – Religious Conversion – Quashing of FIR – Allegations of mass religious conversions of over 100 persons across 37 Hindu families to Islam through allurement, foreign funding, promises of jobs and housing – FIR registered under multiple sections of IPC, Gujarat Freedom of Religion Act, IT Act and SC/ST Act – Petitioners argued that conversions were volunt...
Criminal Law - Rape – Appeal Against Acquittal – Standard of Review – No Interference – State challenged acquittal in rape case – Held: Acquittal grants double presumption of innocence – Unless findings are perverse, Appellate Court must refrain from interfering – Trial Court’s view was plausible and based on appreciation of evidence – Appeal d...
Criminal Law – Conviction Based on Extra-Judicial Confession and Circumstantial Evidence – Acquittal Ordered – The appellant was convicted under Sections 302 and 201 IPC for the alleged murder of his parents based on extra-judicial confessions and recoveries made at his instance – The High Court found that the alleged confessions were made in the presence of police and were...
Criminal Law - Corruption – Illegal Gratification – Sections 7 and 13(1)(d) r/w Section 13(2), Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 – Demand Not Proved – Appellant, a clerk in RTO office, allegedly demanded Rs. 25 for issuing driving licence – Trap arranged but complainant not examined during trial – No explanation by Investigating Officer for complainant’s ...
Criminal Law – Rape and Murder of Minor – Circumstantial Evidence – Appellant convicted for kidnapping, rape and brutal murder of a two-year-old child – Recovery of stolen jewellery and frock of the victim under Section 27 Evidence Act – Presence of accused in locality admitted by defence – Medical evidence confirming sexual assault and death by smothering and d...
Criminal Law – Section 498A IPC – Quashing of Proceedings – Absence of Statutory Ingredients – Held: FIR and charge sheet alleged non-cohabitation and emotional neglect after marriage – No allegation of conduct likely to cause suicide or grave injury – No harassment for unlawful demand made out – Allegations insufficient to constitute cruelty under either ...
Criminal Law - Preventive Detention – Validity of Ordinance – Section 88, Government of India Act – Detention Orders Upheld – The appellants challenged their detention under Ordinance IV of 1949, alleging lack of Governor’s competence under Section 88 and repugnancy with existing laws – Held: Satisfaction of the Governor under Section 88(1) is subjective and not...