Civil Law - Specific Performance – Agreement to Sell – Admission of Signatures and Receipt of Consideration – Defendant admitted encashment of ₹16 lakh via cheques forming part of earnest money – Agreement bore his signatures on all pages including reverse of stamp papers – Held: Once execution and consideration admitted, burden shifted to defendant to prove fraud o...
Service Law – Displacement Quota – Employment – G.O.Ms.No.98 – Delay in Application – Writ petitioner, son of displaced person from Dachuru village, filed application for employment 10 years after displacement – Rejection of claim by authorities citing limitation of one year under G.O.Ms.No.98 – Held: One-year limitation cannot be strictly enforced in ligh...
Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act – Protected Tenancy – Statutory Purchase – Sections 32G & 32M – Effect of Mutation Entries – Exclusive Title – Civil Court Jurisdiction – Plaintiff (sister) filed suit for partition in 2002 claiming suit property as joint family property inherited from parents who died in 1949 and 1978 – Evidence showed t...
Family Law – Divorce – Cruelty – Decree of Divorce Granted – Appellant alleged repeated abusive conduct by wife, threats of suicide, denial of physical relationship, and desertion without cause – Family Court dismissed petition citing isolated nature of incidents and unclean hands due to dowry allegations – Held: Cumulative effect of wife’s behaviour inclu...
Electricity – Crop Damage – Strict Liability – Respondent’s wheat crop destroyed by fire due to electrical short-circuit from a Three Phase LT Line passing over his field – Writ Court directed compensation of ₹50,400 with 6% interest – Defence of natural calamity (wind storm) raised by State rejected – No proof of windstorm placed on record – High ...
Civil Law – Specific Performance – Agreement to Sell – Concurrent Findings – Appellant (Defendant) challenged the decree for specific performance of an agreement to sell land for ₹2,00,000/- – Plaintiff proved payment of ₹1,80,000/- earnest money and execution of agreement via marginal witness and scribe – Defendant admitted signatures but claimed they were ...
Municipal Law – Building Plan Sanction – Mixed-Use Regulations – Whether owner can be compelled to construct commercial ground floor in notified mixed-use streets – Held: No; mixed-use is only permissive, not mandatory – Authorities acted arbitrarily in denying sanction for purely residential construction – Deemed sanction upheld – Directions to approve fr...
Property Law – Partition Suit – Effect of Previous Litigation – Interpretation of Decree – Appellants (Plaintiffs) sought partition of joint property claiming half share – Respondent (Defendant) contended that Appellants lost rights due to failure to pay Rs. 5,300/- as ordered in a previous Second Appeal (S.A. No. 641 of 1988) – First Appellate Court dismissed t...
Arbitration – Execution of Award – Objections by Legal Representatives – Arbitral award dated 12.07.2010 passed in favour of appellant was sought to be executed in Bombay against the father’s estate – Legal representatives (uncle and others) challenged execution by asserting non-party status and independent rights in the property – Held: Since the execution was ...
Debt Recovery – SARFAESI Act – Priority of Secured Creditor – Section 26E of SARFAESI Act grants statutory priority to debts owed to secured creditors post registration – However, this statutory priority does not override a statutory “first charge” under a welfare statute such as EPF&MP Act – Held: While bank’s secured dues get priority over ordi...