Child Custody – Direction to Produce Child – Writ of Habeas Corpus – Contempt of Court Established – The respondent failed to comply with the High Court’s order dated 12.04.2019 in W.P. No. 47795 of 2018, which required her to produce the minor child before the Family Court at Tirupati – Held: Non-compliance constitutes willful disobedience – Subsequent de...
Divorce – Cruelty – Section 13(1)(ia), Hindu Marriage Act – Wife alleged persistent dowry demands, misappropriation of jewellery, repeated assaults including a violent incident on 08.03.2013, and continuous humiliation – Evidence of wife and her father supported allegations – Respondent did not produce any witness or document – Held: Conduct caused grave mental ...
Copyright Infringement – Film piracy – Dynamic+ injunction – Websites restrained from illegally streaming Plaintiff’s film “Jolly LLB 3” – Domain registrars, ISPs, DoT and MeitY directed to block infringing domains – Strong interim relief granted considering imminent release [Paras 34–43].
Commercial Courts Act – Pre-institution Mediat...
Civil Law - Execution of decree for injunction – Executing Court wrongly dismissed application under Order 21 Rule 32 CPC – High Court held even prohibitory injunction enforceable in execution; demarcation can be directed – Order set aside, matter remanded [Paras 7–13].
Civil Procedure – Order 21 Rule 32 CPC – A decree for permanent injunction can be executed...
Taxation Law - Central Excise – Manufacture – Containerized Gensets – Transformation and marketability test applied – Held: Process amounts to “manufacture” under Section 2(f) – Excise duty payable – Appeals dismissed [Paras 21, 33, 50-53].
Central Excise – Manufacture – Section 2(f), Central Excise Act, 1944 – Process of contain...
Probate—Escheat—Locus of State—Sections 8–13, 29, 30 HSA; Sections 63, 263 IS Act—State has no standing to assail probate where Will stands proved and probated—Grant of probate renders escheat inapplicable; Government is a stranger to probate/succession proceedings unless there is failure of heirs upon intestacy—SLPs by State dismissed on locus—Expla...
Negotiable Instruments – Dishonour of Cheque – Secondary Evidence – Xerox copy of cheque permitted as secondary evidence when original was produced, verified, endorsed and later lost – Trial Court order refusing secondary evidence set aside.
Evidence Act – Secondary Evidence – Sections 63 & 65 – Principles reiterated – General rule requires pr...
Criminal Law – Unlicensed Firearms – Suo motu action by Supreme Court – Issue of proliferation and widespread use of unlicensed firearms noticed during hearing of SLP involving Section 302 IPC – Court highlighted that unlike U.S. Constitution, Indian Constitution does not confer a fundamental right to bear arms – Preservation of life under Article 21 necessitates stri...
Criminal Writ – PIL - Constitutional Validity – Section 376DA IPC – Challenge to mandatory life imprisonment “for remainder of natural life” – Question left open – Petitioner assailed the provision as arbitrary and violative of Articles 14 & 21 for excluding judicial discretion and mitigating circumstances – Court held that validity cannot be exa...
Specific Performance – Readiness and Willingness – Section 16(c), Specific Relief Act – Specific Performance Denied – Plaintiff failed to demonstrate financial capacity or readiness to perform obligations under agreement – Held: Plaintiff did not have funds or financing to pay remaining ₹1.75 Cr – Failure to establish readiness and willingness bars specific pe...