Criminal Law – Police Harassment – Herbal Hookah in Restaurant – Petitioner alleged police interference with lawful restaurant operation citing alleged sale of tobacco-laced hookah – Petitioner claimed use of only herbal substances without nicotine – Held: Police not to interfere with restaurant business unless illegal activity is found – Direction issued to pet...
Civil Writ - Industrial Zoning – Use of Land in Food Processing Park – Environmental Impact – Writ Appeal Dismissed as Infructuous – Appellants challenged licence agreement (Ext.P4) issued by KINFRA in 2013 permitting R5 (Malabar Gold Pvt. Ltd.) to establish a gold manufacturing unit in Kakkancheri Food Processing Park – Held: The land was part of a general zone withi...
Preventive Detention – PIT NDPS Act – Habeas Corpus – Detention order and confirmation order quashed due to non-consideration of representation by State Government independent of Advisory Board opinion – Failure to apprise detenu of right to represent to Central Government – Non-consideration of bail orders vitiates detention order – Held: Detention illegal and ...
Tender Law – Bid Evaluation – Technical Disqualification – Arbitrary Selection – Judicial Review – Opposite Party No.2 submitted credentials for work related to sewage pump house and wastewater treatment plant – NIT specifically required experience in “cleaning of overhead tanks/underground reservoirs by mechanical means” – Submitted work order...
Constitutional Law – Articles 200 & 201 – Governor’s and President’s powers – Discretion – No deemed assent – Article 142 cannot substitute constitutional function – Decisions under Articles 200 & 201 non-justiciable – Only limited mandamus permissible for prolonged inaction – Article 361 immunity personal, but institutional actio...
Extradition Law – Dual Criminality – India-Canada Treaty – Prima Facie Satisfaction for Magisterial Inquiry – Validity of MEA’s Decision – Petitioner challenged MEA’s direction under Section 5 of Extradition Act initiating magisterial inquiry into Canadian extradition request for offence under Section 320.16(3) of Canadian Criminal Code – Held: The a...
Banking Law – Classification of Borrower Account as Fraud – Prejudgment in Show Cause Notice – Violation of Natural Justice – Action Set Aside – Petitioner challenged the show cause notice dated 28.02.2024 and the impugned order dated 07.08.2024 whereby respondent Bank of India reclassified the account of M/s Swati Mining Pvt. Ltd. as “Fraud” – Held:...
Administrative Law – Termination of License – Writ Against APTDC – Maintainability – Petitioner challenged termination of license granted under agreement dated 03.10.2020 for operation of shop at Rushikonda Beach – Held: Though APTDC is ‘State’ under Article 12, disputes arising from license agreements are contractual and remedy lies in civil suit for dama...
Constitutional Law – Tribunal Reforms Act, 2021 – Validity – Reenactment of Struck Down Provisions – Challenge to Tribunal Reforms Act, 2021 on grounds of violating judicial directions issued in MBA (IV) and MBA (V) – Court found that impugned provisions in the 2021 Act merely replicated those in the 2021 Ordinance which had already been struck down – Age bar of...
Environmental Restoration – Corbett Tiger Reserve – CEC Supervision – Restitutive Principles – Polluter Pays – Precautionary Principle – Ecocentrism – Expert Committee report accepted – State of Uttarakhand directed to submit restoration plan, demolish unauthorised structures, and comply within time-bound schedule – Restoration to be supervised...