Auction Purchaser Has No Vested Right Without Sale Confirmation: Calcutta HC Upholds Borrower’s Redemption Right Under Pre-Amendment SARFAESI Law Mere Breach of Promise to Marry Doesn’t Amount to Rape: Delhi High Court Acquits Man in False Rape Case Father Is the Natural Guardian After Mother’s Death, Mere Technicalities Cannot Override Welfare of Child: Orissa High Court Restores Custody to Biological Father Assets of Wife and Father-in-Law Can Be Considered in Disproportionate Assets Case Against Public Servant: Kerala High Court Refuses Discharge Identification Without TIP, Electronic Records Without 65B Certificate – Conviction Set Aside: Patna High Court Nothing Inflicts A Deeper Wound On Our Constitutional Culture Than A State Official Running Berserk Regardless Of Human Rights: Jharkhand High Court Orders ₹1.5 Lakh Interim Compensation Dishonour Due to ‘Account Blocked’ Not Attributable to Drawer—No Offence Under Section 138 NI Act: Delhi High Court Quashes Criminal Proceedings Presumption Under Section 139 NI Act Cannot Be Rebutted By Mere Assertions: Delhi High Court Affirms Conviction In 32-Year-Old Cheque Bounce Case Signature Alone Doesn’t Prove Debt: Kerala High Court Upholds Acquittal in Cheque Bounce Case, Rejects Blanket Presumption Under Section 139 NI Act Justice Cannot Be Left to Guesswork: Supreme Court Mandates Structured Judgments in Criminal Trials Across India Truth Must Be Proven Beyond Doubt—Not Built On Flawed FIRs, Tainted Witnesses And Investigative Gaps: Supreme Court Acquits Man in POCSO Rape-Murder Case Once parties agree and reconciliation is impossible, a fault-based decree is unnecessary: Supreme Court Sets Aside Divorce on Desertion No Escape from Statutory Ceiling: Exclusive Expenditure by Foreign Head Offices Also Attracts Section 44C Income Tax: Supreme Court Loss Of A Child Cannot Be Calculated In Rupees, But Law Must At Least Offer Dignity In Compensation: Supreme Court Enhances Compensation Sessions Court Cannot Direct Life Imprisonment Till Natural Life Without Remission: Supreme Court Reasserts Limits on Sentencing Powers of Subordinate Courts ‘Continuously Means Without a Single Break’: Supreme Court Bars Expired-and-Renewed Licences From Police Driver Recruitment Chief Justice’s Power Under Section 51(3) Is Independent and Continuing: Supreme Court Upholds Kolhapur Bench Notification Last Seen Evidence Alone Cannot Sustain Conviction: Supreme Court Acquits Accused in Murder Case No Cultivation on Forest Land Without Central Clearance: Supreme Court Cancels Lease Over 134 Acres, Orders Reforestation Appointment from Rank List Must Respect Communal Rotation: SC Declines Claim of SC Waitlisted Candidate After Resignation of Appointee Supreme Court Dissolves 20-Year Estranged Marriage Under Article 142 Despite Wife’s Objection Murder Inside Temple Cannot Be Treated Lightly: Supreme Court Cancels Bail of Father-Son Convicts in Group Killing Case

"CRIMINAL LAW" Digest

Criminal Law - Murder – Section 302, 304 Part II, 394, 452, 120B, 397 of the IPC - Conviction Altered – Presumption under Section 114(a) Evidence Act – Recovery of Stolen Gold Ornaments – Held: Circumstantial evidence proved that accused 1 robbed the deceased’s gold ornaments and caused her death while committing robbery – However, absence of intent to kill or c...

Quashing of Charges – Discharge of Private Vendor – Sections 120-B, 420, 471 IPC and Section 13(2) r/w 13(1)(d) of PC Act – Discharge Allowed – Applicants sought quashing of orders rejecting discharge and framing charges alleging criminal conspiracy and wrongful gain in award of HMIS project under NRHM – Court held that applicants, being private vendors, completed the...

Criminal Law - Quashing of Criminal Proceedings – Matrimonial Dispute – Settlement Recognized – FIR Quashed - Petition filed for quashing of FIR No. 323/2022 under Sections 323/354/34 IPC on the basis of amicable settlement between husband and wife – Allegations included physical assault, molestation, and threats – The parties executed a settlement deed dated 24.04.20...

Criminal Revision – Allegation of Forgery and Misrepresentation – Section 156(3) Cr.P.C. – Seeking Registration of FIR – Revision Dismissed – The revisionist filed a criminal revision against the Magistrate’s order rejecting his application under Section 156(3) Cr.P.C., seeking registration of FIR against respondent no. 2 (Deputy Chief Minister of U.P.) for alle...

Criminal Law – Quashing 0f FIR - Peaceful Protest – Democratic Dissent – FIR Quashed – Petitioners participated in a non-violent protest against the administrative shift of water distribution meeting venue concerning Jawai Bandh – Held: There was no evidence of violence, incitement, damage to property, or threat to public order – The protest was a legitimate exe...

Criminal Law  – Cognizance Based on Magistrate’s Own Knowledge – Section 210(1)(c) BNSS – Valid Mode of Taking Cognizance – Challenge Rejected – Petitioners, police officials, challenged summons issued under Section 227(1)(b) BNSS on basis of judicial inquiry conducted under Section 196 into alleged custodial death – Held: Magistrate’s power und...

Criminal Law - Section 363, 376 of the IPC & Section 4 of the POCSO Act - Framing of Charge – Scope under Sections 227 & 228 CrPC – Legal Principles Reiterated – Held that at the stage of framing of charge, the court has to sift the evidence for limited purposes to determine whether a prima facie case exists – A strong suspicion suffices but the court cannot act as ...

Criminal Law - Quashing of Charges – Interception of Calls – Section 5(2) of Telegraph Act – Petition Dismissed – The petitioner challenged charges framed under Section 120B IPC read with Section 9 of the PC Act alleging unlawful interception of calls and lack of prima facie evidence – The High Court upheld the legality of interceptions based on public safety and conf...

Cheque Dishonour – Appeal by Complainant – Section 138 NI Act – Appeal Maintainable Under Proviso to Section 372 Cr.P.C. – Not Under Section 378(4) – The complainant had preferred an appeal against acquittal along with an application for leave under Section 378(4) Cr.P.C. – Held: In light of Supreme Court’s ruling in Celestium Financial v. A. Gnanasekaran,...

Anticipatory Bail – Sections 302, 323, and 34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC) - Role Introduced via Supplementary Statement – No Injury Attributed – Bail Granted – The petitioner, aged 67, was not named in the FIR and was later implicated for allegedly catching the victim’s beard and inciting his co-accused to assault – No injury attributed to the petitione...