Criminal Writ - Habeas Corpus - Preventive Detention – Live and Proximate Link – Delay Vitiates Detention – Alleged occurrence on 11.06.2025; arrest on 22.06.2025; detention order on 21.07.2025 – State failed to satisfactorily explain delay – Mere calendrical narration in affidavit insufficient – Applying Anand Prakash (AIR 1990 SC 516) and Sushanta Kumar Bainik...
Criminal Law – Murder - Appeal Against Acquittal – Interference – Principles – High Court reiterates that interference is permissible only when findings are perverse, based on misreading of evidence, or when only one view (guilt) is possible – Double presumption of innocence applies – Trial court’s findings found sound and not perverse [Paras 16–20, ...
Criminal Law – Appeal Against Acquittal – Unlawful Assembly – Assault – Cross-FIR – Evidence of complainant and injured witnesses found to be partisan, contradictory, and inconsistent with their police statements which admitted mutual fight and injuries on opposite side – Suppression of fatal injuries on accused’s father (deceased Ganpatsinh) in cross-case...
Criminal Law – Withdrawal of Prosecution – Permission from High Court Mandatory – Appellant, a former MLA, challenged criminal proceedings arising from FIRs under Arms Act and IPC – State had issued orders to withdraw cases citing public interest, and Public Prosecutor filed withdrawal application before trial court – Held: As per Ashwini Kumar Upadhyay v. Union of In...
Muslim Law – Post-divorce Property – Section 3 of 1986 Act – Return of Dower and Gifts – Appellant claimed ₹17.67 lakhs including ₹7 lakhs and 30 bhories of gold under Section 3 of the Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Divorce) Act – Trial court decreed partial return – High Court reversed, relying on father’s statement that amount was given to hus...
Criminal Law – Discharge – Section 227 CrPC – Discharge granted – Appellant accused of restraining complainant from entering a property during a civil dispute and capturing her photos – High Court upheld dismissal of discharge – Supreme Court held that strong suspicion necessary for framing charges must be based on legally admissible material – Observed th...
Criminal Law – Attempt to Murder – Discharge Order – Accused allegedly chased and assaulted complainant and his injured brothers inside police station – Trial court discharged accused under Section 307 IPC citing absence of fatal injuries – High Court found that statements of victims and police witnesses established intention to cause death – Held: Trial court e...
Criminal Law - NDPS Act – Commercial Quantity – Conviction Confirmed – Appellants found in possession of 550 kg of ganja concealed in oil tanker – Trial court convicted all accused under Sections 20(b)(ii)(C) and 29 of the NDPS Act – High Court upheld conviction, finding that prosecution proved compliance with procedural requirements and guilt beyond reasonable doubt ...
Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 – Section 5 – Provisional Attachment – Limitation of 180 Days – Impact of COVID-19 Period – Orders of Supreme Court in Suo Motu Writ Petition (C) No. 3 of 2020 – Applicability – Held: The limitation extensions granted in SMWP orders were intended to benefit litigants for filing suits/applications/proceedings and do ...
Criminal Law – Appeal Against Conviction - Sections 376(2), 366A IPC, and Section 6 of POCSO Act - Testimony of Child Victim – Credibility and Sufficiency – Conviction Upheld – The child victim aged about 5 years clearly narrated that the appellant lured her to his house under the pretext of giving her toffees and inserted his finger into her vagina and bit her cheeks &ndas...