Trademark Pirates Face Legal Wrath: Delhi HC Enforces Radio Mirchi’s IP Rights Swiftly Madras High Court Upholds Extended Adjudication Period Under Customs Act Amid Allegations of Systemic Lapses Disputes Over Religious Office Will Be Consolidated for Efficient Adjudication, Holds Karnataka High Court Motive Alone, Without Corroborative Evidence, Insufficient for Conviction : High Court Acquits Accused in 1993 Murder Case Himachal Pradesh HC Criticizes State for Delays: Orders Timely Action on Employee Grievances Calls for Pragmatic Approach to Desertion and Cruelty in Divorce Cases: Calcutta High Court Orders Fresh Trial Juvenile Tried as Adult: Bombay High Court Validates JJB Decision, Modifies Sentence to 7 Years Retrospective Application of Amended Rules for Redeployment Declared Invalid: Orissa High Court NDPS Act Leaves No Room for Leniency: HC Requires Substantial Proof of Innocence for Bail No Protection Without Performance: MP High Court Denies Relief Under Section 53A of Transfer of Property Act Delays in processing applications for premature release cannot deprive convicts of interim relief: Karnataka High Court Grants 90-Day Parole Listing All Appeals Arising From A Common Judgment Before The Same Bench Avoids Contradictory Rulings: Full Bench of the Patna High Court. Age Claims in Borderline Cases Demand Scrutiny: Madhya Pradesh HC on Juvenile Justice Act Bishop Garden Not Available for Partition Due to Legal Quietus on Declaration Suit: Madras High Court Exclusion of Certain Heirs Alone Does Not Make a Will Suspicious: Kerala High Court Upholds Validity of Will Proof of Delivery Was Never Requested, Nor Was it a Payment Precondition: Delhi High Court Held Courier Firm Entitled to Payment Despite Non-Delivery Allegations Widowed Daughter Eligible for Compassionate Appointment under BSNL Scheme: Allahabad High Court Brutality of an Offence Does Not Dispense With Legal Proof: Supreme Court Overturns Life Imprisonment of Two Accused Marumakkathayam Law | Partition Is An Act By Which The Nature Of The Property Is Changed, Reflecting An Alteration In Ownership: Supreme Court Motor Accident Claim | Compensation Must Aim To Restore, As Far As Possible, What Has Been Irretrievably Lost: Supreme Court Awards Rs. 1.02 Crore Personal Criticism Of Judges Or Recording Findings On Their Conduct In Judgments Must Be Avoided: Supreme Court Efficiency In Arbitral Proceedings Is Integral To Effective Dispute Resolution. Courts Must Ensure That Arbitral Processes Reach Their Logical End: Supreme Court Onus Lies On The Propounder To Remove All Suspicious Circumstances Surrounding A Will To The Satisfaction Of The Court: Calcutta High Court Deeds of Gift Not Governed by Section 22-B of Registration Act: Andhra Pradesh High Court Testimony Of  Injured Witness Carries A Built-In Guarantee Of Truthfulness: Himachal Pradesh High Court Upholds Conviction for Attempted Murder POCSO | Conviction Cannot Be Sustained Without Conclusive Proof Of Minority - Burden Lies On The Prosecution: Telangana High Court Credible Eyewitness Account, Supported By Forensic Corroboration, Creates An Unassailable Chain Of Proof That Withstands Scrutiny: Punjab and Haryana High Court Jammu & Kashmir High Court Grants Bail to Schizophrenic Mother Accused of Murdering Infant Son

Unchallenged Evidence Is Conclusive: High Court of Delhi Upholds Eviction Order, Validates Unregistered Family Settlement

07 May 2024 8:19 AM

By: Admin


The High Court of Delhi has upheld the eviction order issued by the Additional Rent Controller, North District, Delhi, affirming the bona fide requirement of the landlord under Section 14(1)€ of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958. The judgment, delivered by Justice Girish Kathpalia, underscores the validity of unregistered family settlements and the critical role of unchallenged evidence in tenancy disputes.

Credibility of Family Settlement: The court validated the unregistered family settlement as a legitimate document to establish ownership. “The said family settlement is in fact not an instrument of partition but a documentary record of settlement arrived at between the mother of the present respondent and her children, so as to avoid any property disputes in future,” Justice Kathpalia noted. This aligns with Section 49 of the Registration Act, 1908, which permits unregistered documents as evidence in collateral transactions.

Ownership and Tenant Relationship: The petitioners, Satpal Sharma and Anr., did not dispute the ownership and tenancy relationship. The court highlighted that the eviction petitioner only needs to prove a better title than the tenant. “In the present case, the petitioners are admittedly tenants in the subject premises while the respondent acquired ownership through a registered Sale Deed in favour of her mother, followed by the family settlement,” Justice Kathpalia remarked.

Failure to Contest Evidence: The tenants failed to file a written statement or cross-examine the respondent, Sadhna Arora, leaving her evidence unchallenged. Justice Kathpalia observed, “Despite opportunity, the present petitioners opted not to file a written statement and/or to cross-examine the present respondent.”

The judgment reiterated that the eviction petitioner does not need to establish absolute title, only a better title than the tenant. The court noted, “The other portions of the premises No. C21, Model Town-III, Delhi, are owned by the respondent’s mother and brother, not the respondent, and cannot be treated as available premises for the respondent.”

The High Court’s decision to uphold the eviction order reaffirms the legal principles supporting landlords’ rights under bona fide requirements. By recognizing the validity of unregistered family settlements and emphasizing the importance of unchallenged evidence, this judgment sets a significant precedent for future tenancy disputes. The dismissal of the petition and affirmation of the Additional Rent Controller’s order underscore the judiciary’s commitment to a fair and just application of tenancy laws.

Date of Decision: May 27, 2024

Satpal Sharma & Anr. V. Sadhna Arora

Similar News