-
by kapil
19 November 2026 10:19 AM
"A conjoint reading of the aforesaid provisions makes it abundantly clear that the legislature has consciously prescribed age restrictions separately for an individual man and an individual woman. The statutory scheme does not contemplate as prescribed any cumulative and combined age restriction in respect of commissioning couple," Punjab & Haryana High Court
CHANDIGARH: The Punjab and Haryana High Court has held that the Assisted Reproductive Technology (Regulation) Act, 2021 does not impose a cumulative or combined age restriction on a commissioning couple, ruling that the age criteria under Section 21(g) are individual-specific and reproductive autonomy remains an integral facet of personal liberty under Article 21 of the Constitution of India. A Division Bench comprising Justice Suvir Sehgal and Justice Rajesh Gaur on November 16, 2026, dismissed an appeal filed by the Union of India challenging a Single Judge order that permitted a woman who had crossed the statutory upper age limit of 50 years to undergo In Vitro Fertilization (IVF) treatment.
Respondents No. 1 and 2, a married couple who had previously lost a foetus during an earlier pregnancy facilitated through IVF, approached an ART clinic with the desire to conceive. The clinic declined to provide services on the ground that the wife had crossed the upper age threshold of 50 years prescribed under Section 21(g)(i) of the ART Act. The couple challenged the rejection through a writ petition, which was allowed by a Single Bench directing the authorities to permit the treatment subject to the couple furnishing an undertaking regarding medical risks, prompting the Union of India to prefer the present Letters Patent Appeal.
Whether Section 21(g) of the ART Act, 2021 requires both constituents of a commissioning couple to simultaneously satisfy the age criteria, or whether the age limit is individual-specific?
Whether an infertile couple is disqualified from accessing ART facilities under the ART Act if one spouse exceeds the statutory age limit while the other remains eligible?
Whether the statutory upper age restriction under Section 21(g)(i) infringes upon reproductive choices and personal liberty guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution of India?
Whether the Union of India is estopped from assailing the Single Judge's order after having itself proposed the recourse of an undertaking during the writ proceedings?
Union of India estopped by conduct after proposing undertaking before Single Judge
The Division Bench observed at the threshold that the Union of India had itself suggested during the writ proceedings that the petitioners could be permitted to undergo treatment upon furnishing an undertaking holding themselves responsible for any medical injury. The Single Judge accepted this recourse and granted relief accordingly.
The Court observed that the appellants nonetheless chose to challenge the final order in appeal despite having acquiesced in the arrangement. The Bench held that the appellants were "estopped by their own conduct and acquiescence" after failing to controvert binding coordinate bench precedents and having actively proposed the undertaking mechanism.
ART Act distinguishes individuals from couples without prescribing cumulative age limits
Examining the scheme of the ART Act, 2021, the Bench pointed out that Section 2(1)(n) defines 'patients' as "an individual or a couple who approaches a registered ART clinic for the management of infertility." The Court noted that the legislature explicitly recognised an individual and a couple as distinct legal categories.
The Bench highlighted that while Section 21(g) restricts ART services to women between 21 and 50 years and men between 21 and 55 years, it nowhere stipulates a joint or cumulative age cap for a commissioning couple. Importing an unwritten cumulative age bar would amount to judicial redrafting of the statute.
"Thus, the age criteria under the Act is individual specific and cannot be construed as imposing any additional age restriction based on the combined age of the couple, particularly when no such restriction finds express statutory recognition. Consequently, any interpretation seeking to impose a combined age limit upon a commissioning couple would amount to importing a condition into the statute which the legislature has consciously not prescribed," the Court observed.
Bench adopts Calcutta High Court ruling on eligibility of commissioning couples
To reinforce its interpretation, the Division Bench relied on the Calcutta High Court judgment in Sanchita Ghosh v. Union of India, which held that unless the age bar applies to both spouses simultaneously, a commissioning couple cannot be barred from approaching an ART clinic.
The Court endorsed the principle that if either spouse qualifies under the age limits set out in Section 21(g), the commissioning couple as an entity retains the legal right to access ART facilities. The age-related ineligibility of one constituent does not extinguish the couple's entitlement to seek fertility services.
Blanket age restrictions touch upon reproductive autonomy protected under Article 21
The Bench underscored that reproductive decisions are firmly entrenched within the guarantees of life and personal liberty under Article 21 of the Constitution. Citing the Supreme Court's decisions in K.S. Puttaswamy, Suchita Srivastava, and Vijaya Kumari S., the Court reaffirmed that reproductive autonomy shields intimate choices regarding procreation from unwarranted State interference.
The Court noted that any statutory limitation curtailing reproductive autonomy must withstand the rigorous constitutional tests of reasonableness, non-arbitrariness, and proportionality under Articles 14 and 21.
"In the present context, the prescription of an upper age limit under the ART Act, 2021, without adequate consideration of an individual woman’s health, medical fitness and informed consent, raises substantial constitutional concerns. Such a blanket age-based restriction, if imposed without a rational and proportional justification, may unduly infringe upon a woman's decisional autonomy, bodily integrity and dignity, which constitute integral facets of Article 21 of the Constitution," the Bench observed.
The Division Bench concluded that the Single Judge had committed no error in permitting the respondent wife to undergo ART treatment upon furnishing the requisite undertaking. Finding no merit in the challenge mounted by the central authorities, the High Court dismissed the Letters Patent Appeal and affirmed the relief granted to the commissioning couple.
Date of Decision: November 16, 2026