-
by kapil
19 November 2026 7:59 AM
"To insist upon formal proof in every such case, notwithstanding the passage of several decades and the unavailability of the persons directly connected with the transaction, would often render the adjudication of longstanding proprietary rights unduly difficult and, in some cases, impossible," Calcutta High Court
KOLKATA: The Calcutta High Court has held that registered instruments of remote antiquity produced from proper custody and free from suspicion attract the statutory presumption under Section 90 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, obviating the necessity of producing direct oral testimony to prove their due execution. A single judge bench of Justice Prasenjit Biswas on November 17, 2026 ruled that recitals regarding legal necessity and delivery of possession in century-old conveyances executed by Hindu widows cannot be lightly brushed aside where the original parties and attesting witnesses are long deceased and the challenging parties fail to substantiate allegations of fraud.
The suit property originally belonged to three brothers having an undivided one-third share each. Upon the intestate death of two brothers, their widows, Kusumi and Sashi, inherited their shares and transferred them to the plaintiffs' predecessor through two registered sale deeds in 1924, explicitly citing existing debts and inability to manage the property as legal necessity. The defendants, successors of the surviving brother, resisted the plaintiffs' suit for declaration and injunction by asserting that the widows were unchaste, lacked legal necessity, committed fraud, and alternatively that the defendants had perfected title through adverse possession.
The primary legal issues before the High Court were whether the lower appellate court erred in failing to arrive at a definite finding regarding legal necessity for alienation by the widows under traditional Hindu law, whether the registered sale deeds of 1924 required formal proof under the Indian Evidence Act, and whether the defendants could simultaneously sustain a claim of reversionary inheritance alongside a plea of adverse possession.
Addressing the evidentiary hurdles of remote transactions, the High Court observed that when deeds are more than a century old, direct oral evidence regarding their execution or reading over of contents to executants cannot practically be expected from successors who were not even born at the time.
Presumption under Section 90 Evidence Act protects ancient conveyances from impossible standards of formal proof
Justice Biswas noted that Section 90 of the Indian Evidence Act embodies a rule of necessity and convenience designed to secure longstanding proprietary transactions. When documents exceeding thirty years of age are produced from proper custody without suspicious alterations, the law dispenses with the insistence on calling attesting witnesses or scribes who are no longer alive.
The bench stressed that while registration does not conclusively prove every recital, production of registered title deeds from the custody of vendees, supported by recitals of delivery of possession, raises a strong evidentiary foundation that requires the challenging party to adduce cogent rebuttal evidence rather than relying on bare denials.
Recitals of legal necessity in ancient deeds carry significant evidentiary weight in the absence of rebuttal
Turning to the question of legal necessity under classical Hindu law governing a widow's limited estate prior to the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, the Court ruled that the nature of alienation must be tested against the contemporaneous recitals of the deed. The 1924 deeds expressly recorded outstanding family debts and the absence of caretakers after the death of another brother.
The Court held that recitals explaining the circumstances necessitating the sale cannot be rejected in the abstract when decades have elapsed and both sides lack direct personal knowledge. Since the defendants produced no evidence demonstrating that the recited family debts were fictitious, the challenge to the widows' authority to alienate failed.
Allegations of fraud and unchastity require strict proof and cannot rest on unsubstantiated assertions
The bench emphatically rejected the defendants' plea that the widows had become unchaste and abandoned the family property. The Court highlighted that the defendants failed to identify the alleged paramours or places of residence, while their own defense witness admitted seeing the widows residing in the ancestral bastu during their lifetimes.
The Court reiterated that general allegations of fraud or misrepresentation without material particulars cannot invalidate registered conveyances that have subsisted undisturbed for decades.
Mutually destructive pleas of reversionary heirship and adverse possession cannot be sustained on vague pleadings
The High Court further depreciated the defendants' dual defense of claiming reversionary title on the one hand and adverse possession on the other. Referring to Supreme Court precedents, the bench reiterated that adverse possession requires clear pleading and proof of the exact date of commencement, hostile animus against the true owner, and uninterrupted possession for the statutory period.
The Court observed that a claimant cannot merely rest on long-standing possession to assert adverse possession while simultaneously claiming title through succession as reversioners, particularly when both pleas lack foundational evidence.
The High Court accordingly affirmed the judgment and decree of the First Appellate Court declaring the plaintiffs' two-thirds share and granting a permanent injunction, while dismissing the second appeal preferred by the defendants.
Date of Decision: November 17, 2026