-
by kapil
19 November 2026 7:59 AM
KOLKATA: Observing that the sentencing calculus under capital jurisprudence can no longer remain restricted to the traditional crime and criminal tests but must intrinsically integrate the plight and trauma of the victim, the Calcutta High Court on November 17, 2026, confirmed the death sentence awarded to a man for the brutal rape and murder of a five-and-a-half-year-old girl.
A Division Bench comprising Justice Arijit Banerjee and Justice Apurba Sinha Ray ruled that where an unremorseful offender abuses a relationship of trust to commit catastrophic sexual atrocities and fatal violence on a defenseless child, aggravating circumstances heavily outweigh mitigating factors, completely foreclosing the alternative option of life imprisonment under Sections 103(1), 65(2), and 66 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, read with Section 6(1) of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012.
The prosecution case stemmed from an incident on November 24, 2024, where the minor victim was lured with chocolates by the appellant, her neighbour whom she addressed as "Jethu" (uncle), into his house. Following a search by her parents and co-villagers, the victim was recovered unconscious, naked, and bleeding profusely from her private parts under a blanket inside the appellant's residence, and was pronounced dead on arrival at the hospital. Forensic examination and DNA profiling matched the appellant’s semen on the victim's genitalia, and autopsy revealed fatal intracranial haemorrhage resulting from violent impact against a hard surface. The Exclusive POCSO Court, Chinsurah, convicted the appellant and awarded the death penalty, leading to the reference and criminal appeal.
Whether the circumstantial evidence, bolstered by forensic DNA reports and the failure of the accused to offer an explanation under Section 106 of the Evidence Act, proved the guilt of the convict beyond all reasonable doubt.
Whether modern criminal jurisprudence mandates an independent "Victim Test" to balance the rights and lasting trauma of the victim and her family against the mitigating circumstances of the offender during capital sentencing.
Whether the probability of reformation was conclusively ruled out to establish that the case falls within the "rarest of rare" doctrine warranting confirmation of the death penalty under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, and the POCSO Act.
Dismissing the appellant's challenge to the conviction, the High Court held that the prosecution had conclusively established an unbroken chain of circumstantial evidence. The Bench observed that the victim was last seen being lured by the appellant, was recovered within an hour inside his room, and the forensic DNA evidence irrefutably confirmed the presence of the appellant's genetic material in the swabs collected from the victim's labia and perineum.
Failure to offer explanation under Section 106 of the Evidence Act seals the chain of circumstantial guilt.
Writing a concurring opinion, Justice Arijit Banerjee highlighted that the discovery of the victim's grievously injured body inside the appellant's exclusive dwelling placed a heavy burden on him under Section 106 of the Evidence Act to explain the incriminating circumstances. The Court held that his outright denial during examination under Section 313 of the Code of Criminal Procedure was entirely false, noting that the medical and scientific evidence fully corroborated the testimony of search party witnesses.
Modern victimology makes victim trauma an indispensable component of the capital sentencing calculus.
In a comprehensive analysis of sentencing philosophy, Justice Apurba Sinha Ray introduced the dimension of the "Victim Test" as an essential complement to the crime and criminal tests enunciated in Bachan Singh v. State of Punjab. The Court observed that victimology has transformed victims from marginalized spectators into substantive participants possessing statutorily recognized participatory rights.
The Bench observed that criminal courts must apply empathetic judicial contemplation to understand the devastation wrought upon surviving relatives:
"It is a well-settled principle in probate and testamentary jurisdiction that a Judge, while construing a will, must place himself in the 'armchair of the testator' to discern his true intent. By parity of reasoning, a Judge presiding over a criminal court, particularly in cases involving heinous atrocities, must be equally attuned to placing himself, in judicial contemplation, beside the deathbed of the victim or within the harrowing environment of the victim's grieving family, so as to truly comprehend the profound trauma and devastation inflicted."
Lack of remorse and ingrained criminal instinct negate any abstract scope of reform or rehabilitation.
Evaluating the psychological and psychiatric evaluations placed on record pursuant to guidelines in Manoj v. State of Madhya Pradesh, the Court noted that the convict suffered from no mental illness, intellectual deficiency, or emotional disturbance. The Court found that the convict displayed absolute callousness and zero remorse, maintaining brazen denial despite incontrovertible scientific evidence. The Bench held that reformation requires an intrinsic willingness to readjust, which cannot be assumed in a predator with ingrained anti-social propensities.
Public exchequer cannot be burdened to subsidize hardened predators as monuments to misplaced mercy.
The Court strongly rejected the defence plea to commute the sentence to life imprisonment for the remainder of natural life without remission under the Swamy Shraddananda framework. Justice Sinha Ray observed that commuting such a sentence would perversely force society and the grieving parents to finance the lifetime sustenance of a brutal predator:
"Society has no stake in transforming a brutal child-killer into a state-maintained ward, nor does it harbour any collective desire to enshrine a convicted predator as a perverse monument to misplaced mercy."
Justice Banerjee agreed that extending any judicial leniency would amount to misplaced mercy, emphasizing that the appellant turned from a trusted elder into a depraved predator:
"The rape of a minor girl child is nothing but a monstrous burial of her dignity in the darkness... The appellant cannot expect any leniency, indulgence or claim any human right having committed an inhuman wrong."
The High Court accordingly confirmed the death reference and dismissed the appeal preferred by the convict, upholding the conviction and death sentence passed under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, and the POCSO Act. Taking serious note of the State's delay in disbursing interim relief, the Court directed the State of West Bengal to enhance the victim compensation from Rs. 10 Lakhs to Rs. 15 Lakhs and pay the same to the victim’s parents within two months. The Bench stayed the operation of the judgment for three months to enable the convict to approach the Supreme Court.
Date of Decision: November 17, 2026