-
by kapil
19 November 2026 7:59 AM
CHANDIGARH: Observing that commencement of investigation prior to the registration of an FIR creates ample room for deliberation and fabrication, the Punjab and Haryana High Court has set aside the conviction and life sentence of an accused under Sections 302 and 364 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC) and Section 3(2)(v) of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989. A Division Bench comprising Justice Rajesh Bhardwaj and Justice Puja Chopra delivered the verdict on November 5, 2026, holding that demarcation memos under Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act are legally inadmissible when the crime scene was already within the prior knowledge of the investigating agency.
The case originated from the discovery of the body of a 17-year-old boy deliberately arranged on the driver’s seat of an accidental vehicle on the Dinod-Kusumbhi road in April 2013. The complainant alleged that the appellant harboured a caste-based grudge arising from an elephant procession dispute and had abducted and murdered his son. The Additional Sessions Judge, Bhiwani convicted the appellant in May 2014 based on circumstantial evidence, disclosure statements, and recoveries.
Whether an investigation initiated prior to the formal registration of an FIR vitiates the prosecution's narrative and dismantles the last-seen theory.
Whether a demarcation or pointing memo under Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act holds evidentiary value when the spot of occurrence was already known to the police.
Whether the trial court erred in shifting the burden onto the accused to prove a vehicular accident, contrary to fundamental principles of criminal jurisprudence.
Whether a conviction under Section 3(2)(v) of the SC/ST Act can survive when the foundational offences under the Indian Penal Code fail.
The High Court scrutinized the timeline of the investigation and determined that the unexplained delay in lodging the FIR, compounded by the police commencing proceedings hours before the complaint was lodged, was fatal to the prosecution. Independent witnesses and police depositions confirmed that officers were already on the spot in the morning hours, while the written complaint was recorded only in the evening.
Investigation commenced prior to the formal registration of the FIR
The Court noted that the dead body had been initially spotted in the morning by an independent village Sarpanch (DW1), who had alerted the police long before the complainant appeared on the scene. Relying on the Supreme Court's ruling in Sekaran v. State of T.N., the bench held that unrecorded pre-FIR investigations lead to tainted proceedings and false implication.
"Thus, there is not only delay in registration of the FIR, but even the investigation started prior to the registration of FIR due to which this Court finds that enough time was gained by prosecution to deliberate and fabricate a story with a view to falsely implicating the accused as mentioned in the complaint. The story of last seen is, thus, rejected," the bench held.
Section 27 Evidence Act inapplicable to locations already known to police
Addressing the demarcation memo regarding the neem tree where the victim was allegedly tied and rammed with a vehicle, the bench held that it lacked statutory validity under Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act. The rough site plan and crime scene reports prepared earlier by the investigating officer had already documented the tree and vehicle impressions prior to the memo being executed.
"In view of Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 the pointing memo (Ex.P10) is inadmissible in evidence as no new fact pursuant thereto was discovered. Thus, the prosecution has not been able to connect the accused with the crime scene," the Court ruled, noting that no independent witnesses were joined despite being present in adjoining fields.
Prosecution cannot draw strength from weaknesses in defence
The Court firmly rejected the trial court’s reasoning that the accused was obligated to prove how the deceased sustained accidental injuries while inside the car. The bench reiterated that criminal law does not permit shifting the foundational burden of proof onto an accused.
Citing the Supreme Court decision in Sunil Kundu v. State of Jharkhand, the bench emphasized that the prosecution must stand or fall on its own legs and cannot rely on a failed defence under Section 313 CrPC. The trial court committed a serious illegality by reversing the burden of proof against settled cannons of law.
"The same is against the settled position in law that the burden of proof is on prosecution and the weakness of defence cannot come to the aid of prosecution, which is obliged to prove the case beyond reasonable doubt against the accused. Thus, learned trial Court wrongly placed the reverse burden on the accused/appellant against settled cannons of law," the bench observed.
Circumstantial chain snapped by unnatural witness conduct
Applying the Sharad Birdhichand Sarda framework, the Court found the circumstantial links wholly incomplete. The conduct of the complainant and his brother was found to be unnatural under the test laid down in Rathinam v. State of T.N., as it was unbelievable that a father, having discovered his son dead in a vehicle at night, would simply return home without informing the police.
Furthermore, the alleged caste motive failed as the juvenile co-accused belonged to a Scheduled Caste, and the complainant's brother admitted in court that he had no knowledge as to why his nephew was killed. Under Nandu Singh v. State of M.P., the complete failure of the prosecution to establish motive in a circumstantial case strongly tilts the scales of justice toward acquittal.
Charges under Section 364 IPC and SC/ST Act fall to the ground
Examining the abduction charge under Section 364 read with Section 362 IPC, the Court observed that the allegations were purely hearsay. The person who allegedly informed the father was never examined in court, meaning no evidence existed to prove that the deceased was compelled or induced by deceitful means.
Since the underlying offences under Sections 302 and 364 of the IPC were not proved beyond reasonable doubt, the bench held that the consequential charge under Section 3(2)(v) of the SC/ST Act also could not survive.
Allowing the appeal, the High Court set aside the judgment of the trial court and acquitted the appellant of all charges under Sections 302 and 364 IPC and Section 3(2)(v) of the SC/ST Act, ordering the immediate discharge of his bail bonds.
Date of Decision: November 5, 2026