Criminal Law – Murder – Appreciation of Evidence – Sole Eyewitness – Conviction can rest on testimony of a solitary witness only if his presence is natural, and his version is wholly reliable and free from contradictions – Where witness changes version, gives improbable account and is of doubtful credibility, conviction unsafe [Paras 16–18].
Criminal Procedur...
Criminal Law – Rape and Murder of Minor – Circumstantial Evidence – Appellant convicted for kidnapping, rape and brutal murder of a two-year-old child – Recovery of stolen jewellery and frock of the victim under Section 27 Evidence Act – Presence of accused in locality admitted by defence – Medical evidence confirming sexual assault and death by smothering and d...
Criminal Law - Preventive Detention – Validity of Ordinance – Section 88, Government of India Act – Detention Orders Upheld – The appellants challenged their detention under Ordinance IV of 1949, alleging lack of Governor’s competence under Section 88 and repugnancy with existing laws – Held: Satisfaction of the Governor under Section 88(1) is subjective and not...
Criminal Law – Murder Conviction – Scope of Interference by Supreme Court – Appellant convicted by Sessions Judge and conviction confirmed by Punjab High Court – Evidence of five eye-witnesses, including mother of deceased, accepted by both courts – Held: Supreme Court not a regular court of criminal appeal and will not re-weigh evidence where concurrent findings of f...
Criminal Law – Murder – Dying Declarations – Acquittal – Deceased Sarla suffered 90% burns in her matrimonial home – Three dying declarations recorded – In first two statements (Exh. D-3 and Exh. P-3), deceased stated she sustained injuries accidentally while cooking – In third dying declaration (Exh. P-18), recorded three days later by Executive Magistrat...
Constitutional Law – Freedom of Speech – Sedition – Sections 124A & 505 IPC – Validity upheld – Challenge to constitutionality of Sections 124A and 505 IPC on the ground that they violate Article 19(1)(a) – Held: The provisions, when read in light of Article 19(2), are valid – The restrictions imposed are “in the interests of public order” ...
Criminal Law – Murder – Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC – Applicability – Appellant convicted for murdering deceased Kaluram by inflicting a knife blow on his chest – defence plea that incident occurred in a sudden fight without premeditation and hence case fell under Exception 4 to Section 300 IPC – Held: Exception 4 applies only when death is caused (a) without...
Criminal Law – NDPS Offence – Conscious Possession – Meaning and Scope – Conviction under Section 15 NDPS Act requires proof of conscious possession – Possession implies control with awareness of its nature – Once possession established, burden shifts to accused under Sections 35 and 54 NDPS Act to explain innocence – However, failure to question accused o...
Criminal Law - Corruption – Illegal Gratification – Sections 7 and 13(1)(d) r/w Section 13(2), Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 – Demand Not Proved – Appellant, a clerk in RTO office, allegedly demanded Rs. 25 for issuing driving licence – Trap arranged but complainant not examined during trial – No explanation by Investigating Officer for complainant’s ...
Criminal Procedure – Section 319 CrPC – Power to summon additional accused – Nature and scope – Held: Power is extraordinary and discretionary – To be exercised sparingly and only when compelling reasons exist – The evidence relied upon must be such that, if unrebutted, it would reasonably lead to conviction – Mere statement of witness or FIR reiteration i...