Limitation - Condonation of Delay – Inordinate Delay – Application Rejected - The appellant sought condonation of a 4486-day delay in filing the appeal, attributing it to alleged professional misconduct by previous counsel and subsequent pursuit of an application under Order IX Rule 13 CPC. The Court held that the appellant, a corporate entity, failed to demonstrate sufficient cause fo...
Arbitration Law – Interpretation of Limitation under the Madhya Pradesh Madhyastham Adhikaran Adhiniyam, 1983 – Limitation period extended due to consent of parties – Petitioner’s claims remanded – The petitioner contended the arbitration tribunal's dismissal of claims as time-barred, arguing the extension of the dispute resolution period by mutual consent –...
Suits for Permanent Injunction – Necessity of Title Proof – Requisite Pleading – Suit Dismissed: Where the plaintiff fails to prove ownership of the disputed property, a suit for permanent injunction simpliciter is not maintainable. Both lower courts correctly applied the principles laid down in Anathula Sudhakar v. P. Buchi Reddy, (2008) 4 SCC 594 – Held: Plaintiff temple ...
Service Law – Financial and Pensionary Benefits – Work Charge Employee – Entitlement to Pension and ACP – Petitioner sought financial and pensionary benefits, claiming that her deceased husband’s services should be regularized from 2003, making her eligible for benefits like ACP, medical allowance, leave encashment, LTC, etc. – The Court held that as a work char...
Service Law - Employment Eligibility – Acquittal and Criminal Record – Rejection of Candidature Overturned - Petitioner’s application for Constable post was rejected citing pending criminal proceedings under Sections 323 and 143 IPC – Petitioner was acquitted before document verification, and the Court held that mere involvement in criminal proceedings without a conviction ...
Professional Misconduct – Clause (7), Part I, Second Schedule, Chartered Accountants Act, 1949 – Gross Negligence – Issuance of Utilization Certificates without adequate verification – Council of ICAI held respondent guilty of professional misconduct for certifying financial statements without corroborating documents and failing to disclose reliance on other sources –...
Appointment of Non-Teaching Staff – Requirement of Prior Approval – Appellant challenged the decision of the Single Judge which quashed the orders of the DIOS disapproving the appointment of the respondent as an Assistant Clerk – Argument that minority institutions are exempt from seeking prior approval as per Regulation 101 of the Act – Single Judge held Regulation 101 ina...
Guardianship – Article 226 – Appointment of Guardian for Person in Comatose State – Petition filed under Article 226 seeking declaration of the petitioner as the guardian of her husband, who is in a persistent vegetative state due to a cerebrovascular stroke – Held: No existing legislation for appointing a guardian in such cases; Court invoked parens patriae jurisdiction to...
Matrimonial Law – Divorce – Grounds of Cruelty – Long Separation – Held: Prolonged separation of 24 years with complete absence of reconciliation efforts constitutes mental cruelty under Section 13(1)(ia) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 – The bitterness and irretrievable breakdown of the marriage fulfill the cruelty threshold – Divorce granted [Paras 26-29].
...
Order XXXVIII, Rule 5 CPC – Attachment Before Judgment – Plaintiff sought direction for defendants to furnish security and injunction on bank account operations to secure the amount allegedly due for goods supplied – Defendants disputed the quality and quantity of goods, and denied liability – Court held no prima facie case made by plaintiff to warrant attachment before jud...