CBI Can’t Prosecute When Bank Suffers No Loss: Andhra Pradesh High Court Discharges Bhimavaram Hospitals Directors in ₹1.5 Crore SBI Case Section 256 CrPC Cannot Be A Shield For An Accused Who Never Faced Trial: Allahabad High Court Restores 8 Cheque Bounce Complaints Minimum Wages Cannot Be Ignored While Determining Just Compensation: Andhra Pradesh High Court Re-Fixes Income of Deceased Mason, Enhances Interest to 7.5% 34 IPC | Common Intention Is Inferred From Manner Of Attack, Weapons Carried And Concerted Conduct: Allahabad High Court Last Date of Section 4 Publication Is Crucial—Error in Date Cannot Depress Market Value: Bombay High Court Enhances Compensation in Beed Land Acquisition Appeals Order 26 Rule 10-A CPC | Rarest of Rare: When a Mother Denies Her Own Child: Rajasthan High Court Orders DNA Test to Decide Maternity Acquittal Is Not a Passport Back to Uniform: Punjab & Haryana High Court Upholds Dismissal of Constable in NDPS Case Despite Trial Court Verdict Limitation Under Section 468 Cr.P.C. Cannot Be Ignored — But Section 473 Keeps the Door Open in the Interest of Justice: P&H HC Non-Stamping Renders A Document Inadmissible, Not Void – Defect Is Curable Once Duty Is Paid: Punjab & Haryana High Court Upholds Specific Performance MP High Court Upholds Ladli Behna Yojana Criteria; Rules Registration Deadlines and Age Limits Fall Under Executive Domain Criminal Courts Are Not Recovery Agents: Orissa High Court Grants Bail in ₹3.5 Crore Land Fraud Cases Citing Article 21 and Terminal Illness

victim compensation cannot be imposed while granting bail - SC

07 May 2024 8:19 AM

By: Admin


The Supreme Court in Case Titled Talat Sanavi Vs State of Jharkhand & Anr. Dated 24 Jan 2023 ,  while dealt with the issue of whether interim victim compensation can be imposed as a condition for grant of anticipatory bail, held that interim victim compensation cannot be imposed as a condition for granting anticipatory bail.

Supreme Court observed that the "victimology" movement in the 1960s led to the introduction of monetary compensation for victims of crime as an incentive for cooperation in criminal prosecutions. Canada and several states in the US started providing victim compensation, leading the way for victim justice initiatives in the criminal justice system. The UN Declaration on Basic Principles of Justice for Victims and Abuse of Power (1985) provided specific rights and entitlements for victims of crime, including the right to compensation

Supreme Court further observed that Section 357 of the Code of Criminal Procedure in India provides for the payment of compensation when a court imposes a fine or sentence, but with limitations on payment before the appeal period has elapsed or before the decision of the appeal. The compensation is for the person who has suffered loss or injury as a result of the crime committed. The appellate court or the High Court can also direct payment of compensation when exercising its power of revision.

Supreme Court quashed the condition imposed for interim victim compensation while granting anticipatory bail and allowed the appeal and held Victim compensation is determined at the same time as the final view of the alleged offense, i.e., after a verdict has been reached, and cannot be imposed before the matter is finalized. The impugned bail order suffered from an infraction of law as the question of interim victim compensation cannot form part of the bail jurisprudence, victim compensation is only determined after the conclusion of trial and cannot be imposed pre-trial.

TALAT SANVI VS STATE OF JHARKHAND & ANR.            

Latest Legal News