-
by kapil
21 November 2026 3:55 PM
"A plain reading of the aforesaid provision makes it clear that a Court other than the Juvenile Justice Board, including a learned Magistrate, is empowered to inquire into a claim of juvenility and record a finding regarding the age of the accused," Delhi High Court.
NEW DELHI: The Delhi High Court, in an order passed by Justice Manmeet Pritam Singh Arora on November 19, 2026, held that a Metropolitan Magistrate possesses statutory jurisdiction under Section 9(2) of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015 to conduct an age inquiry and declare an accused a child in conflict with law. The Court affirmed that school records pre-dating the dispute carry statutory precedence under Section 94(2)(i) over private marriage declarations, and private complainants have no independent vested right to cross-examine school officials during such inquiries.
The dispute arose out of FIR No. 251/2020 registered at PS North Rohini under Sections 188, 323, 341, 379, 506, and 34 of the Indian Penal Code against the petitioner's former fiancée and her family. Following her arrest, the accused raised a plea of juvenility, leading the Metropolitan Magistrate to determine her date of birth as November 1, 2003, based on verified school leaving records, and declare her a child in conflict with law. Aggrieved, the complainant challenged the order contending that subsequent marriage certificates and court custody warrants had recorded her birth year as 1999, and that only the Juvenile Justice Board possessed the jurisdiction to conduct the inquiry.
Whether a Magistrate has the statutory jurisdiction under Section 9(2) of the Juvenile Justice Act, 2015 to decide a claim of juvenility or if such determination is the exclusive domain of the Juvenile Justice Board under Section 8(1)?
Whether verified primary school admission records take precedence over subsequent conflicting third-party declarations under Section 94(2) of the Juvenile Justice Act, 2015?
Whether a private complainant has a vested right to cross-examine school authorities during an age determination inquiry conducted under the Juvenile Justice Act, 2015?
Magistrates Have Explicit Jurisdiction Under Section 9(2) To Determine Juvenility Claims
Addressing the jurisdictional challenge raised by the petitioner, the High Court scrutinized Section 8 and Section 9(2) of the Juvenile Justice Act, 2015. The bench held that the exclusive jurisdiction conferred on the Juvenile Justice Board under Section 8(1) is explicitly subject to the other provisions of the enactment, which encompasses inquiry by regular courts.
The Court observed that Section 9(2) explicitly authorizes any court other than a Board to make an inquiry and take necessary evidence to determine the age of a person claiming to be a child. The bench noted that the statutory wording recognizes such a claim at any stage before any court, thereby rendering the jurisdictional challenge to the Magistrate’s inquiry completely untenable.
School Records Retain Primacy Under The Section 94 Hierarchy
Examining the merits of the age determination, the bench highlighted the statutory hierarchy governing proof of age under Section 94(2) of the JJ Act. The Court emphasized that entry-level school records hold statutory priority over other secondary materials or subsequent conflicting declarations made before private bodies.
The bench pointed out that the records obtained from three government schools consistently recorded the accused’s date of birth as November 1, 2003, originating from her first school admission in April 2010. The Court emphasized that these records pre-dated the dispute between the parties by nearly a decade and were backed by parental affidavits submitted at the time of admission.
Subsequent Conflicting Declarations Cannot Discredit Contemporaneous School Entries
Addressing the complainant’s reliance on marriage deeds and Arya Samaj certificates from 2020 and 2021 that showed the accused as a major, the Court held that these documents could not displace authenticated, contemporaneous government school records.
The Court noted that the petitioner could utilize such discrepancies to mount a defence in any collateral criminal proceedings, but they were insufficient to dislodge the statutory preference mandated by Section 94(2)(i) of the JJ Act.
Complainant Holds No Vested Right To Cross-Examine School Authorities
The High Court decisively rejected the petitioner's argument that the inquiry was vitiated due to the denial of an opportunity to cross-examine the school principals or record keepers. Citing the Supreme Court’s ruling in Rekha Murarka v. State of West Bengal, the Court reiterated the primacy of the Public Prosecutor in criminal proceedings under Sections 225, 301(2), and 24(8) of the CrPC.
The bench held that a private victim or complainant does not possess a vested right to conduct an independent inquiry or cross-examine official witnesses when the prosecution has expressed satisfaction with the authenticity of verified official school records.
Dismissing the revision petitions, the High Court held that the Metropolitan Magistrate committed no illegality or material irregularity in declaring the accused a child in conflict with law based on verified primary school records. Consequently, the connected revision petition challenging the termination of the proceedings before the Juvenile Justice Board was also dismissed.
Date of Decision: November 19, 2026