-
by kapil
21 November 2026 3:55 PM
"The principle of open justice means proceedings are generally open to the public to attend. However, the same does not amount to 'free broadcast' by any unauthorized individual," Allahabad High Court
PRAYAGRAJ: The Allahabad High Court has held that the doctrine of open justice cannot be stretched to permit the unauthorized recording or broadcasting of judicial proceedings, observing that courtrooms are dedicated to serious legal determinations and cannot be reduced to content for public entertainment or digital trials. Underscoring the inherent jurisdiction of the court to regulate its proceedings and maintain institutional decorum, Justice Vikram D. Chauhan on November 19, 2026, directed an absolute prohibition on litigants carrying mobile phones into courtrooms, holding advocates solely responsible should their clients breach the restriction.
The stringent regulatory directives were passed during the hearing of a petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, after the Additional Government Advocate alerted the Bench that an unauthorized individual was secretly capturing video recordings of ongoing courtroom proceedings on a smartphone. The Bench Secretary took custody of the device, which revealed three recorded courtroom videos, while the individual admitted he lacked permission and was carrying an entry pass valid solely for advocates' chambers rather than courtrooms. Taking serious note of assertions that the individual was escorted into the room by an advocate's junior, the Court initiated contempt-related custody proceedings and summoned the involved lawyers to show cause.
Whether the constitutional guarantee of open justice confers an unbridled right upon individuals to record or broadcast court proceedings without the prior leave of the court?
Whether the unauthorized filming and prospective circulation of judicial proceedings on social media platforms constitutes an impermissible interference with the administration of justice?
Whether the High Court has the inherent authority to regulate courtroom decorum by prohibiting litigants from possessing mobile phones and fixing professional responsibility on advocates?
Addressing the scope of courtroom access, the High Court observed that while judicial proceedings are fundamentally accessible to the public, such transparency cannot be exploited for unapproved dissemination or private circulation.
Court proceedings cannot be repurposed as social media content or entertainment
The Court highlighted that judicial proceedings deal with high-stakes matters concerning the liberty, reputation, and substantive rights of individuals, demanding an atmosphere of strict solemnity rather than digital voyeurism.
"It is not in the interest of the litigants that their personal details be broadcasted on the social media and discussed as the court proceedings are not for entertainment purpose but is a serious business affecting liberty and rights of an individual," the Bench observed.
The Court warned that unmonitored digital recordings expose litigants to extra-judicial public scrutiny and prejudice before courts can arrive at a definitive finding on merits.
Premature digital exposure creates parallel trials and stigmatizes victims
Pointing out that the Bench routinely adjudicates criminal matters involving child sexual abuse, individual liberties, Central Bureau of Investigation inquiries, and Enforcement Directorate probes, the Court underscored the acute danger of publishing sensitive facts.
"The publishing or recording such judicial proceedings without leave of the Court may have the effect of social media trial without even the final determination in the court proceedings and may adversely affect the court proceedings or the right of litigant," the Court remarked, adding that victims could face severe social stigma if their harassment is uploaded to digital networks.
Affirming its institutional authority, the Bench held that each Presiding Officer retains inherent power to govern the immediate precinct of the courtroom to preserve order and confidentiality.
Broadcast of judicial proceedings remains strictly subject to judicial leave
The Court ruled that the regulation of courtroom broadcasts is non-negotiable and lies solely within the supervisory discretion of the presiding judge.
"In view of the aforesaid, the broadcast is required to be regulated by Presiding Officer of each Court and no person has the right to record the court proceedings except with the leave of the Court," the Bench held.
Taking note of a circular issued by the President of the High Court Bar Association imposing a cost of Rs. 5,000 on lawyers making reels or taking photos inside court premises, the Bench reprimanded the practice of lawyers facilitating unauthorized public access.
Counsel made strictly responsible for ensuring litigants do not carry mobile phones
To prevent recurring lapses and safeguard institutional security, the Court barred all litigants from entering courtrooms with mobile devices and shifted the compliance burden onto legal practitioners.
"In view of the situation prevailing in the Court and concerning the security of the Court, the litigants shall not be permitted to enter into the court rooms along with mobile phones. If the mobile phone is found with any of the litigant in the court room, then the concerned Advocate is solely responsible for the same. It is for the Advocates to strictly instruct their clients not to bring mobile phones into the court room," the order directed.
The High Court directed the Court Officer to take the individual into custody for production before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Prayagraj, with a provision for bail upon furnishing personal bonds and sureties, alongside an explanation as to why his actions should not be treated as interference in the administration of justice. The Court additionally directed the petitioner's counsels to appear in person and show cause why proceedings should not be initiated against them, while ordering the Registrar (Protocol) to enforce mobile phone restrictions on litigant entry passes across the High Court.
Date of Decision: November 19, 2026