-
by kapil
21 November 2026 3:55 PM
RANCHI: Affirming that the non-recovery of the murder weapon is not fatal to the prosecution's case when circumstantial evidence forms an unbroken chain, a division bench of Justice Rongon Mukhopadhyay and Justice Ram Sharma on November 19, 2026, dismissed an appeal against conviction under Section 302 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code. The High Court held that proximate last seen evidence, motive rooted in an unpaid loan, and the failure of the accused to discharge the burden under Section 106 of the Indian Evidence Act conclusively established guilt.
The prosecution case stemmed from a fardbeyan lodged by the deceased’s brother, alleging that on the intervening night of February 17 and 18, 2009, the appellant and co-accused intercepted the deceased's commercial vehicle and persuaded him to stop at a roadside hotel. The appellant thereafter took the deceased away in another vehicle towards the southern side of the establishment, following which the deceased never returned. The victim’s body was recovered the next morning approximately one kilometer away bearing severe cranial trauma, and the trial court convicted the appellant to undergo rigorous imprisonment for life.
Whether the circumstantial evidence satisfied the Panchsheel principles to sustain a conviction under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC in the absence of direct eyewitness testimony?
Whether an approximate time-of-death estimation by the autopsy doctor could demolish the proximate last seen together theory established by credible witnesses?
Whether the non-recovery of the weapon of assault by the investigating officer was fatal to the prosecution's case?
Evaluating the legal matrix governing circumstantial evidence, the Court reiterated the settled principles laid down in Gambhir v. State of Maharashtra and Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra, emphasizing that the circumstances must unerringly point towards the guilt of the accused and exclude every reasonable hypothesis of innocence.
Last seen proximity and un-impeached witness depositions conclusively establish movement of deceased with accused
The bench scrutinized the testimonies of the cleaner and the informant, noting that they consistently proved that the appellant intercepted the deceased, engaged in conversation at the hotel, and led him away in his vehicle just hours before the corpse was discovered.
The Court observed that both prosecution witnesses stood firm through rigorous cross-examination without contradiction.
"In absence of any contradictions, the evidence of P.W.1 and P.W.6 appears to be trustworthy and inspire confidence which leads to an inference that the appellant Pankaj Kr. Choudhary not only reached the Yadav Hotel on the alleged night, but, also took him to the southern side of the hotel and thereafter, the deceased was not seen with anyone else rather his dead body was recovered from that direction in the morning of the next day."
Doctor's approximate estimation of time of death cannot override clinical limits and proximate last seen testimony
Addressing the appellant’s contention regarding a minor variance between the witness accounts and the doctor's estimation that death occurred more than twenty-four hours prior, the bench invoked the ratio in Bodhraj v. State of Jammu & Kashmir to underline that medical estimates made solely upon visual and clinical post-mortem examinations are approximations rather than exact mathematical determinations.
The bench ruled that such estimations do not negate the proximate time gap between the deceased being seen alive with the appellant and his subsequent demise.
Failure to explain departure from deceased's company under Section 106 Evidence Act forms crucial missing link
Highlighting the statutory duty cast on the accused once last seen proximity is established, the bench referred to Rajender v. State (NCT of Delhi) to emphasize that an accused is bound to provide a credible explanation as to when and how he parted company with the deceased, as facts within his special knowledge cannot be left unaddressed.
The Court observed that the appellant merely set up an uncorroborated plea in his Section 313 CrPC statement that the informant was elsewhere, without confronting the prosecution witnesses with that assertion during cross-examination.
Absence of murder weapon does not impair conviction where chain of incriminating circumstances remains intact
Rejecting the argument that the failure to recover the weapon of assault undermined the prosecution, the bench cited the Supreme Court’s decision in Rakesh v. State of U.P., holding that production of the crime weapon is not an indispensable prerequisite for securing a conviction for murder.
The Court pointed out that because the appellant was arrested months after the incident, the inability of the investigating machinery to unearth the weapon could not be termed fatal.
Finding no infirmity in the trial court's assessment, the High Court held that the prosecution had proved the homicidal death, motive of a defaulted loan, proximate last seen circumstance, and recovery of the body with cogent evidence, thereby dismissing the appeal and canceling the appellant's bail with a direction to surrender within four weeks.
Date of Decision: November 19, 2026
Case Title: Pankaj Kr. Choudhary v. The State of Jharkhand
Bench: Justice Rongon Mukhopadhyay and Justice Ram Sharma
Counsel for Appellant: Advocate Girish Mohan Singh
Counsel for Respondent/State: Additional Public Prosecutor Manoj Kumar Mishra