Subsequent Declaration Of Juvenility Does Not Vitiate Conviction On Merits: Supreme Court Borrowers Cannot Ignore Bank Accounting Systems And Suspense Accounts To Claim Arbitrary Reductions In Loan Dues: Supreme Court Re-employed Judicial Officers Cannot Claim 6th Pay Commission Scales: Supreme Court Supreme Court Slams High Court For Erroneously Exercising Review Jurisdiction On 'Mistaken Notion', Restores Employee's ACP Benefits Trademark Infringement: Defendant Can Cross-Examine Plaintiff On Use Of Brand Name Even If Written Statement Is Not On Record: Supreme Court 'Interest And Welfare Of Child Would Be Best Served': Supreme Court Invokes Parens Patriae In Contempt Plea; Revokes Own Custody Order Mere Absence From MCA Records Cannot Absolve Accused Under Section 138 NI Act If Prima Facie Role Is Shown: Punjab & Haryana High Court Incomplete Or Defective Real Estate Application Cannot Claim Deemed Registration Under Section 5(2) Of RERA Act: Orissa High Court Mere Criminal Antecedents Cannot Justify Invoking 'Organized Crime' Offence Under Section 111 BNS Without Fulfilling Statutory Ingredients: Madhya Pradesh High Court 'Testator's Character & Prior Gifts Justify Unequal Distribution': Madras High Court Upholds Holographic Will Minority Status Cannot Arrest Limitation Period For Appeal If Minor Was Represented By Natural Guardian In Original Proceedings: Madhya Pradesh High Court Mere Admission Of Property Boundaries In Family Partition Deeds Destroys Coparceners' Claim That Land Remains Joint Ancestral Property: Karnataka High Court Mesne Profits Must Reflect Open Market Letting Value Rather Than Static Contractual Rates: Delhi High Court Law Graduates Who Fail To Clear AIBE Within Two Years Cannot Practice In Any Court, Tribunal Or Revenue Authority: Allahabad High Court Bombay High Court Slams 'Growing Tendency' To Bypass GST Appeals, Says 'Natural Justice' Not A Blanket Excuse For Writ Petitions Proportionate Cost Only Can Be Awarded On Decreed Amount, Not On Total Plaint Valuation: Kerala High Court

No Compliance of Section 42(2) Of NDPS Act – Rajasthan High Court Suspend Sentence

07 May 2024 8:19 AM

By: Admin


The High Court of Judicature for Rajasthan at Jodhpur, in a notable judgment ([2023:RJ-JD:40022]), underscored the necessity of strict adherence to the procedural mandates of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (NDPS) Act. The observation was made in the context of a suspension of sentence appeal by Asad Ahmed, who was earlier convicted under Sections 8/15(c) of the NDPS Act.

Hon’ble Mr. Justice Farjand Ali, in his ruling dated November 21, 2023, emphasized the importance of legal compliance, stating, “It is an admitted position that no compliance of Section 42(2) of NDPS Act was made in this present case.” This significant statement highlighted the court’s focus on the procedural aspects of the NDPS Act in determining the legality of the narcotics seizure and arrest.

The judgment critically examined the role and authority of the seizing officer, noting the lack of proper empowerment under Section 42 of the NDPS Act. The court pointed out the procedural irregularities in the seizure operation, particularly the failure to comply with mandatory provisions like informing a superior officer before proceeding with search and seizure, as mandated under Section 42(2).

Acknowledging these procedural lapses, the court decided to suspend the sentence of the petitioner, who had been sentenced to ten years of rigorous imprisonment. The suspension of the sentence was based on the potential reevaluation of the issues raised by the appellant, which might lead to an acquittal. Additionally, the court considered the duration already served by the appellant and the long pendency of the appeal.

While suspending the sentence, the court also set forth several bail conditions, including the execution of a personal bond and sureties. It also mandated regular appearances of the accused before the trial court and outlined the trial court’s duty in ensuring compliance with these conditions.

Date: 21/11/2023

ASAD AHMED VS STATE OF RAJASTHAN

Latest Legal News