Service Law – Pay Scale – Upgradation vs. Promotion – Respondents claimed higher pay scales on completion of service milestones without promotion – Upgradation of posts merely provided financial benefit without changing duties – Supreme Court holds that claim based on office order for next higher pay scale without assuming higher responsibilities is misconceived &ndas...
Service Law – Appointment – Two candidates recommended for a single post – Initial appointee pursuant to High Court's order – Subsequent recommendation for another candidate – High Court erred in directing appointment of second candidate without affecting initial appointee – Two persons cannot be appointed to a single post – High Court’s order se...
Service Law – Appointment Validity – Appellants were appointed temporarily on leave vacancies and did not pass the speed test for Hindi Stenographers – High Court rightly quashed their appointments and upheld the termination of Respondent Nos. 1 to 3 who were selected through due process – Rule 14(3) validity of the select list was one year, expired on 13.07.1988 – No...
Service Law – Misconduct – Quantum of Punishment – Respondent, a CRPF constable, misbehaved, abused, and injured a doctor on duty and made false criminal charges of sexual harassment against the doctor – High Court substituted the penalty of removal from service with confinement in quarter guard jail – Supreme Court held that the punishment by the disciplinary authori...
Service Law – Submission of Documents – Applicants required to submit all necessary documents along with the application form by the cut-off date – Respondent failed to submit NCC 'B' certificate with original application – Certificate submitted three years after the cut-off date – Not entitled to additional five marks [Paras 1-10].
Judicial Review – ...
Service Law – Compassionate Appointment – Respondent's application for compassionate appointment delayed by the appellants – Respondent crossed the age of 50 years, making employment impractical – High Court awarded Rs.10 lakhs compensation – Supreme Court modified to Rs.5 lakhs due to delay caused by appellants [Paras 6-11].
Compensation for Delay – The ...
Service Law – Promotion – Respondent's promotion withheld due to disciplinary action leading to 'censure' – Bank’s rules specify 'censure' as a minor penalty – Adoption of sealed cover procedure for respondent’s promotion due to pending disciplinary action – Supreme Court held that promotion recommendations in a sealed cover cannot be e...
Service Law – Retrospective Seniority – The High Court erroneously granted retrospective seniority to the respondent from 20.11.1985, a date when he was not borne in service – Respondent entered service only on 10.2.1996 following Supreme Court's direction – Jurisprudence in service law advises that retrospective seniority cannot be claimed from a date when an employee ...
Service Law – Change of Date of Birth – Delay and Laches – Application for change of date of birth in service records must comply with relevant statutory provisions – Karnataka State Servants (Determination of Age) Act mandates application within three years from date of birth recording or within one year from Act commencement – Employee's application made 24 year...
Service Law – Judicial Appointments – Criminal Antecedents – Candidate involved in multiple criminal cases acquitted, but not honorably – High Court allowed writ petition for appointment to Civil Judge post – Supreme Court emphasized the importance of judicial officers’ integrity and public confidence – Found committee's decision to deny appointment ba...