Provisional/Confidential Results – Validity – The Supreme Court held that provisional/confidential results declared by universities are valid for determining eligibility for employment, provided their authenticity is confirmed by the universities. In this case, the provisional results of B.Ed. examinations provided to the candidates before the cut-off date were valid, and the High Cour...
Service Tax – Video Production Agency – Video-Tape Production – Interpretation of Definitions – Nature of services rendered during Video-Tape Production – Circular dated 09.07.2001 – Expressions “services relating thereto” – Conjoint reading of Sections 65(119) and 65(120) of the Finance Act, 1994 – Correctness of Tribunal’s interpr...
Service Law – Recruitment – Qualification – Degree Holders – Interpretation of "minimum" qualifications for Junior Engineer (Electrical) – Whether degree in Electrical Engineering is considered higher than diploma and if degree holders are eligible – Supreme Court held that recruitment rules allowed for interpretation including degree holders – A...
Service Law – Transfer Order – Summoning of Public Officers – Public officers should not be called to court unnecessarily – Courts must avoid exerting undue pressure on administrative officers – Separation of powers between Judiciary and Executive must be respected to maintain constitutional balance – Frequent summoning of officers criticized and condemned [Para...
Administrative and Service Law – Eligibility for Public Employment – Disqualification based on educational qualification – Conflict in interpretation of educational certificate – Applicant declared ineligible after participating in the selection process – Duty of the employer to provide a rational and justifiable reason for rejection – Failure to seek clarificat...
Service Matter - Appointment and Continuance in Service - Dispute regarding the appointment of the appellant and Respondent No.5 - Appellant appointed by the Managing Committee constituted on 15.12.1992, and the appointment cannot be termed illegal or void ab initio - Lack of vacancy on 07.01.1993 for the appointment of Respondent No.5 - Interim order of the High Court in favor of the Managing Com...
Service Law – Selection – Post of Police Constable – Involvement in Criminal Cases – High Court's lenient approach towards youth involved in petty crimes criticized – Supreme Court emphasizes that generalizations leading to condoning misconduct should not influence judicial verdicts – Importance of maintaining public confidence in the police force highlighte...
Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 – Section 11-A – Power of Labor Court to interfere with charges – Applicability and scope – Labor Court has the right to reappreciate the evidence and come to a different conclusion – Charges can be interfered with if necessary. (Para 21)
Labor disputes – Writ jurisdiction – High Court’s supervisory jurisdic...
Service Law – Appointment Eligibility – The appellants were candidates for the post of High School Assistants (Natural Science) in Kerala. The Kerala Public Service Commission (KPSC) disputed the eligibility of their B.Ed degrees, which were in Biological Science, for meeting the required subject criteria. The appellants produced Government Orders (GOs) confirming their degrees as equi...
Uttar Pradesh Recruitment of Dependants of Government Servants Dying in Harness Rules – Compassionate Appointment – The Supreme Court upheld the High Court's decision to grant the respondent the benefit of compassionate appointment. The Court ruled that the father of the respondent, although termed a Part Time Tubewell Operator, was effectively treated as a regular employee due to ...