Criminal Law – Quashing of FIR – Section 528 BNSS – Scope of Judicial Interference – Petition sought quashing of FIR alleging that the petitioner, as Channel Head of Zee Rajasthan, extorted money and threatened vendors with adverse news coverage – Held: Allegations in FIR prima facie disclose cognizable offences – Court cannot evaluate evidence or conduct a &ldq...
Criminal Law – Quashing under Section 482 CrPC – Economic Offences – Bank Fraud – PC Act – One-time Settlement – Held: High Court erred in quashing FIR and chargesheet solely on settlement; grave financial fraud, fabrication of documents, loss to public exchequer, and involvement of bank manager under PC Act make quashing impermissible – Proceedings restor...
Criminal Law – Murder – Acquittal – Appellants convicted for murder and other offences based on evidence of injured witnesses (P.W.1, P.W.2) and others – Trial Court sentenced A1 under Section 302 IPC and A3 to A5 under 302 r/w 149 IPC – On appeal, High Court found inconsistencies in time of occurrence, contradictions in medical and eyewitness testimonies, and suppres...
Criminal Law – Prevention of Corruption – Bribe Demand and Acceptance – Accused public servant allegedly demanded ₹1500 from complainant to release subsidy amount of ₹3000 – Trap conducted by ACB – Accused caught with tainted currency – However, Demand Draft for subsidy not found tainted – Evidence showed that DD was handed over before any contact with...
Criminal Law – Bail – Cancellation and Modification – Judicial Discipline – Finality of Orders – Appellant (accused in a murder case) sought modification of condition restricting him to city limits of Kolkata – Co-applicant sought cancellation of his bail alleging intimidation of witnesses and political interference – Court held that no breach of bail term...
Anticipatory Bail – SC/ST Act – Matrimonial Dispute – Accused sought pre-arrest bail in a case involving alleged caste-based verbal abuse and assault of wife by husband and co-accused – Complainant had protection order under Domestic Violence Act – No prima facie material found to indicate grievous injury or fracture – Allegations under SC/ST Act held to be vagu...
Criminal Law – Rash and Negligent Driving – Sections 279 & 304A IPC – Accused convicted for causing death of a pillion rider by driving autorickshaw rashly and negligently – Courts below relied on consistent testimonies of eyewitnesses (PWs 1, 3, 4), spot sketch (Ex.P11), inquest and post-mortem reports – Held: Conviction based on credible evidence – Defence...
Criminal Law – Quashing of Complaint – Vicarious Liability – Directors – Petitioners sought quashing of complaint filed in 1994 under IPC and Excise Act citing lack of specific allegations – Court held that in absence of averments indicating personal role or statutory vicarious liability, criminal prosecution against directors (Petitioners 3 to 9) is not sustainable &...
NDPS Act – Bail – Commercial Quantity – Section 37 NDPS Act – High Court granted bail without recording mandatory satisfaction under Section 37 – Allegation involved concealment of 731.075 kg of ganja ingeniously hidden in a lorry owned and driven by accused – Supreme Court held that such bail violates settled law requiring strict compliance with Section 37 &nda...
Criminal Law – Second FIR Quashed – Abuse of Process – Appellant was prosecution witness in CBI case involving bribe to GST officials – Following his adverse deposition against university management, second FIR registered accusing him of harboring the accused – Police filed cancellation report but Magistrate took cognizance on protest petition – Supreme Court he...