Criminal Law – Attempt to Commit Rape – Prima Facie Case Not Made Out – Summoning Order Modified – The revisionists were summoned for attempt to commit rape (Section 376 read with Section 18 of POCSO Act) based on allegations that they grabbed the victim’s breasts, broke the string of her lower garment, and attempted to drag her beneath a culvert – The Court hel...
Criminal Law - Unlawful Assembly – Mere Presence at Scene – Reversal of Acquittal Set Aside – Accused Appellants Not Proven to Be Part of Mob – The appellants were named in the FIR and arrested at the spot during a riot involving over 1000 people – The High Court reversed their acquittal based solely on presence at the crime scene – Held: Mere presence, without ...
Criminal Law - Murder – Alteration of Conviction – Sudden Fight Without Premeditation – Conviction Altered to Section 304 Part I – The appellant was convicted under Section 302 IPC for assaulting the deceased with a stick while his co-accused used the blunt side of an axe – Held: The incident occurred in a sudden fight without premeditation, and the nature of weapons ...
Criminal Law - Quashing of FIR – Preliminary Stage of Investigation – Permissibility of High Court Interference – High Court declined to quash FIR observing that investigation was at infancy stage and liberty was granted to produce documents before the investigating agency – Held: Such approach is unheard of and mechanical – Court is duty-bound to examine the plea for...
Criminal Law – Murder – Appeal against conviction – Common Intention – Eyewitness Testimony – Section 302/34 IPC – Conviction Converted – Appellants accused of beating deceased with belcha and kassi during worksite quarrel – Sole eyewitness PW-17 testified to quarrel and dragging of body, but did not witness actual assault – Trial court convict...
Criminal Proceedings – Cross FIRs between Advocates – Quashing in Interest of Justice – Incident arose from personal animosity between two lawyers – First FIR registered by appellant alleged physical assault; second FIR by respondent alleged abuse and threats – Supreme Court held both FIRs stemmed from same transaction and prolonged animosity – Quashed both FIRs...
Criminal Law - Abduction for Ransom – Conspiracy and Execution – Section 364A, 120B IPC – Conviction Upheld - The appellants conspired and executed the abduction of Partha Roy Burman, inflicting gunshot injuries during the kidnapping and detained him at a secluded location to demand ransom – Multiple prosecution witnesses, including PW31 and PW32 (cooks), PW33 (co-accused t...
Criminal Law – Murder – Appeal against conviction - Inconsistent Witness Testimony – Conviction Set Aside – Deceased Mohan Singh was allegedly attacked by five men – Trial Court convicted all; High Court acquitted one – Remaining four appellants challenged conviction – Supreme Court found key prosecution witnesses (family members) gave embellished versions...
Criminal Contempt – Allegation against Sitting Judges – Scandalizing the Court – Contemnor accused Judges of accepting bribes for dismissal of his writ petition – Complaint addressed to the President of India – Held: Allegation scandalizes the Court and tends to lower its authority within meaning of Section 2(c)(i) of the Contempt of Courts Act – Contemnor's...
Criminal Law – Murder – Circumstantial Evidence – Appeal against conviction – Appellant (A1) convicted by Trial Court under Sections 302, 201, 420, 380, and 120-B IPC for the alleged murder of the deceased, his employer and relative – Allegation of staging accident using a car to eliminate deceased due to business rivalry – High Court found major contradictions ...
