Quashing of Proceedings – Absence of Prima Facie Case – Application Allowed – The petitioner was charged under the IPC and Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act, 1956, after being apprehended at a location allegedly used as a brothel. Examination of the case diary revealed that the petitioner was present as a customer, with no allegations or evidence indicating involvement in managing...
Criminal Law – Quashing - Possession of Knife – Applicability of DAD Notification – Sections 25, 54, and 59 of the Arms Act – Quashing of FIR and Chargesheet - The appellant was charged under the Arms Act for possessing a buttondar knife with dimensions lesser than those specified in the Arms Rules. The prosecution relied on the DAD Notification (1980), which regulates cert...
Criminal Law - Post Settlement FIR - Mutual Settlement – Quashing of FIR – Abuse of Process Prevented - The matrimonial disputes between petitioner No.1 and Prabhjot Kaur, including spousal support and custody, were resolved in Australia, where both parties are citizens. Respondent No.2’s initiation of criminal proceedings in India was held to be an abuse of process, as mutual se...
Negotiable Instruments Act – Complaint filed by Power of Attorney Holder in their own name – Not Maintainable – A power of attorney holder cannot file a complaint under Section 138 of the N.I. Act in their own name but may do so on behalf of the payee or holder in due course. The complaint is invalid unless the power of attorney holder has personal knowledge of the transaction, a...
Criminal Law – Kidnapping with Intent to Murder – Respondents acquitted by the trial court – Prosecution’s case based on the testimony of PW2-Dharmendra Kumar and other witnesses – Trial court found no evidence of intent to kill or to dispose of the victim in a manner that endangered his life – Acquittal affirmed by High Court due to lack of substantial evidence...
Criminal Law – Murder – Conviction overturned - Dying Declarations – Conflicting Evidence – Two inconsistent dying declarations formed the basis of the prosecution's case – Court observed significant discrepancies in the deceased's statements regarding specific overt acts by the accused – Decision: The Court held it unsafe to convict the accused solely b...
Dowry Harassment and Cruelty – Section 498A IPC – Insufficient Evidence – Appellant alleged harassment and demands for ₹1,50,000/- on two occasions for job recruitment and transfer – Trial Court found no corroboration for the incidents, with gaps in medical and material evidence – Held: Mere allegations without supporting evidence cannot sustain conviction under Sec...
Criminal Law – Murder Conviction – Appellant convicted for the murder of Girija Devi – Eyewitness account from the informant (mother-in-law of the deceased) contradicted by her own statements and other witnesses declared hostile – Conviction based on unreliable sole testimony – No motive or recovery of the weapon – Appellant acquitted due to lack of evidence [Pa...
Criminal Law - Murder – Circumstantial Evidence – Lack of Cogent Proof – Appeal Allowed – Acquittal - The appellant was convicted for murder and other offenses based on circumstantial evidence, including allegations of motive, discovery of skeletal remains, and DNA profiling. The Supreme Court held that the prosecution failed to establish any credible evidence linking the a...
Family Law – Interim Maintenance – Execution of Maintenance Orders – Appeal Dismissed – The appellant challenged the execution of an interim maintenance order passed under Section 36 of the Special Marriage Act, contending that the order was not enforceable under Section 39A, which applies to orders passed under Chapters V or VI, while Section 36 is in Chapter VII – H...