Criminal Law – Quashing - Proclaimed Person – Mandatory Compliance of Section 82 CrPC / Section 84 BNSS – Mechanical Declaration Set Aside – Trial Court declared the petitioner a proclaimed person on the basis of alleged execution of warrants through family members and unexecuted non-bailable warrants – No proper satisfaction recorded that the petitioner had abs...
Anticipatory Bail – National Security Offences – Alleged Syndicate for Aiding Illegal Immigrants – Seriousness of Allegations – Rejection Upheld – Appeal filed against order rejecting anticipatory bail in offences under IPC, Foreigners Act and Passport Act – Allegations of being kingpin of syndicate providing illegal assistance, financial support and settlement ...
Criminal Law – Bail – Recall of Bail Order – Distinction Between Recall and Cancellation – Petition under Section 482 CrPC filed by CGST Department seeking recall of bail granted by learned CMM – Held: Challenge to grant of bail on merits stands on a different footing from cancellation of bail based on supervening circumstances – Bail order can be interfered wit...
Criminal Law - Prevention of Corruption Act – Demand and Acceptance of Bribe – Proof – Conviction Upheld – Accused, Village Man, alleged to have demanded and accepted ₹500 as illegal gratification for facilitating transfer of Jama rights and land revenue mutation – Prosecution relied on evidence of complainant (PW1), decoy witness (PW2) and trap proceedings – ...
Defamation – False Criminal Complaint – Statements in Judicial Proceedings – Petitioners alleged that respondent lodged a false criminal complaint in 2008 causing humiliation, mental agony and reputational harm – Held: Statements made in a police complaint or judicial proceedings can give rise to prosecution under Sections 499 and 500 IPC – No absolute immunity availa...
Criminal Law – Truncation of Proceedings – Hostile Prosecutrix – In a prosecution for gang rape, prosecutrix resiled completely from allegations and denied sexual assault – Statement under Section 164 Cr.P.C. disowned – Held, where star witness demolishes prosecution case, continuation of trial would be futile – Trial court justified in truncating proceedings an...
Preventive Detention – PITNDPS Act – Territorial Jurisdiction – Forum Conveniens – Writ Petition Dismissed – Petitioner challenged detention order passed by Joint Secretary, Department of Revenue, Government of India and rejection of representations – Though detention order and memoranda were issued from Delhi, predicate offences, sponsoring authority, records a...
Quashing of Proceedings – Scope under Section 528 B.N.S.S. – At the stage of quashing, Court is required to see whether allegations in FIR and material collected disclose prima facie commission of offence – Detailed appreciation of evidence or adjudication of disputed facts impermissible – Where allegations disclose ingredients of offences, proceedings cannot be quashed [Pa...
Bail – Spurious Liquor Deaths – Multiple Accused – Differentiated Role – Six bail applications arising out of a single case involving alleged manufacture, supply and sale of spurious liquor leading to death of five persons and hospitalization of several others – FIR disclosed consumption of liquor purchased from petitioners and co-accused – Charge-sheet filed fo...
Constitutional Law – Validity of Legislation – Section 17A, Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 – Upheld (with interpretation) – The Court examined the constitutional validity of Section 17A of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, which mandates prior approval for inquiry or investigation into offences committed by public servants in discharge of official functions or dut...