Financial Law – One Time Settlement (OTS) – Extension of Time – Section 13(2) SARFAESI Act – Article 226 Constitution of India – Petitioner sought extension for payment of balance OTS amount – Respondent-Bank refused extension citing non-discretionary nature of OTS scheme – Held: High Court has jurisdiction to extend OTS period in equitable jurisdiction un...
Service Law - Regularization of Non-Teaching Staff – Letters Patent Appeal – Non-teaching staff of PICTES sought regularization akin to teaching staff – Single Judge granted regularization and pay scale difference for 38 months – Government's denial based on financial constraints found arbitrary and discriminatory – Appeals dismissed. [Paras 1-16]
Equ...
Personal Security - Withdrawal of Security Cover – Appeal – Decorated police officer's security cover withdrawn by state – Court finds no vested right to personal security – Individual must demonstrate real and genuine threat, not mere apprehension – State’s assessment of threat perception upheld in absence of reliable contrary evidence – Appeal dismis...
Industrial Disputes - Retrenchment Permission – Writ Petition – Company sought permission to retrench 37 workers due to reduced demand during COVID-19 – Labour Commissioner failed to communicate decision within 60 days – Deemed permission granted under Section 25-N(4) – Court finds no infirmity in the deemed permission – Petition dismissed, legality of grounds f...
VAT Law - Input Tax Credit on Evaporation Loss – Appeals – Haryana Tax Tribunal allowed ITC on evaporation losses of petrol and HSD – State appealed citing Entry 5 of Schedule E – Tribunal's decision upheld – Full Bench finds petroleum products’ evaporation losses allowable under prescribed limits – ITC not to be reversed on such losses – Circums...
GST Law - Detention of Goods – Writ Petition – Alleged tax evasion due to minor discrepancy in quantity of copper goods in transit – Invoice and e-way bill showed 10430.7 kg, actual weight 10520 kg – Discrepancy less than 1% – Tax already paid Rs.12,76,717.68 – Claimed evasion Rs.11,000 – Petitioner offered to pay additional tax and penalty – Court f...
Hindu Succession Act - Interpretation of Will – Regular Second Appeal – Will construction requires complete reading to understand testator’s intent – No explicit restriction in will on wife’s right to alienate property during her lifetime – Contingent provision for property succession after wife's death without intestate succession becomes redundant if wife ...
Family Law - Divorce on Grounds of Cruelty and Desertion – Appeal – Family Court dismissed husband's petition for nullity and divorce – Husband alleged cruelty and desertion – Court finds marriage irretrievably broken – Parties living separately for over 10 years – Continuous separation presumed as broken marriage – Appellant's petition under Secti...
Service Law - Cut-off Date for Eligibility - Appeals – Haryana Civil Service (Executive Branch) – Eligibility determined based on 01.11.2018 as cut-off date – Single Bench's interpretation extending cut-off date to 12.07.2019 found incorrect – Rule 9(1)(a)(iii) clearly specifies eligibility based on age and service requirements as of 01.11.2018 – Decision upheld, ...
Family Law - Divorce on Grounds of Cruelty – Appeal – Family Court granted divorce to the husband on grounds of cruelty – Wife appealed, challenging the admissibility of electronic evidence and findings of cruelty – High Court upheld Family Court's decision – Held, Family Courts have wide discretion under Section 14 of the Family Courts Act, 1984, to admit evidenc...