Constitutional Law - Writ Petition under Articles 226 and 227 - UGC Regulations - Denial of Benefits of Senior Scale/Selection Grade - Petitioners were Lecturers initially appointed on a temporary basis and later on a permanent basis - Temporary service period not considered for benefits of Senior Scale and Selection Grade - Held, service period during ad hoc/temporary appointment followed by regu...
Election Law - Interference by Courts in Election Matters – The petitioner filed for mandamus to direct cancellation of nomination paper of Respondent No.5 for the post of Panch, alleging fraudulent voter registration – Held, once election process starts, courts should not interfere as per Article 243-O of the Constitution and Section 176 of the Haryana Panchayat Raj Act – Petiti...
Constitutional Law - Writ Petition under Article 226 - Motor Vehicles Act - Cancellation of Permits - Due Process - Petitioners' stage carriage permits cancelled without notice due to non-payment of tax during Covid-19 lockdown - Petitioners admitted tax liability but were not given a chance to explain or pay in lump sum before permits were cancelled - Held, Section 86 of the MV Act requires o...
Education Law - Writ of Mandamus and Certiorari – Petitioner sought release of Class XII results withheld under the category 'Not Eligible' – Held, Clause 42(v) of CBSE Examination Bye-laws, which requires students to clear compartment exams in the first attempt, is valid – No grounds to rewrite the clause – Petitioner's challenge to the clause is legally untena...
Land Law - Ownership Dispute - Writ Petition under Article 226 - Petitioner sought to quash the orders dismissing his petition and statutory appeal under Section 11 of the Punjab Village Common Lands (Regulation) Act, 1961. The petitioner claimed ownership and possession of Nazul land as a successor by will, whereas the Gram Panchayat asserted ownership per Jamabandi for the year 2004-2005. The Co...
Civil Law - Correction of Date of Birth in Educational Records - Regular Second Appeal against the concurrent findings of fact - Correction of date of birth in matriculation certificate - Held, a student's date of birth can be corrected if proven by valid evidence despite the absence of specific bye-laws allowing such correction - Appeal dismissed - In the present case, the student successfull...
Insurance Law - Repudiation of Claim - Pre-existing Illness - Writ Petition for Certiorari and Mandamus – Insurance company repudiated claims for two life insurance policies on grounds of suppression of material facts, specifically chronic diseases (diabetes mellitus and hypertension) of the insured – Insurance Ombudsman upheld the repudiation – High Court found no independent in...
Land Acquisition Law - Limitation for Reference – Appeal against dismissal on Limitation Grounds – Appeal challenging the dismissal of reference under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act due to limitation – Reference Court found the application filed after three years from the date of knowledge of the award when compensation was received – High Court held that the Refere...
Civil Service Law - Regularization of Service - Seniority List vs. Log Book - Appeal challenging the de-regularization of service by relying on the seniority list over a log book. Appellant claimed an earlier date of appointment based on the log book. Held that the log book, being in the custody of the employee and used only for recording certain facts, cannot supersede the seniority list, which i...
Employee’s Compensation – Jurisdiction – Section 21 – Deceased driver killed during employment – Commissioner at Nuh awarded compensation – Appellant contended lack of jurisdiction as incident occurred in Mathura, UP – Court held jurisdiction valid where dependents reside or employer has registered office – Procedural notice irregularity does not pre...