Unauthorised Absence Not Synonymous With Wilful Absence; Disciplinary Authorities Cannot Discard Medical Evidence On Mere Conjectures: Supreme Court

17 November 2026 9:07 PM

By: sayum


"Absence from duty without prior permission may constitute unauthorised absence; however, unauthorised absence and wilful absence are not necessarily synonymous," Supreme Court.

NEW DELHI: Observing that absence from duty without prior sanction does not automatically establish wilful insubordination and that disciplinary authorities cannot reject medical records as fabricated on mere conjectures, the Supreme Court on November 16, 2026 set aside the removal of a Central Reserve Police Force (CRPF) constable who overstayed his leave by 99 days due to illness. A Bench comprising Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh held that the circumstances surrounding the absence, including bona fide medical incapacitation, must be objectively evaluated before imposing capital departmental penalties.

The appellant, a CRPF constable deployed in Jammu and Kashmir, was granted casual leave in September 2000. He failed to rejoin duty on the scheduled date and reported back after a delay of 99 days, explaining that he was undergoing medical treatment for infective hepatitis in Bihar and could not communicate due to ill health and local constraints. Rejecting his medical documents on the assumption that they were written with the same pen and lacked outdoor patient registration numbers, the disciplinary authority removed him from service. While a Single Judge of the Patna High Court quashed the removal order, the Division Bench reversed the decision on the premise that the Single Judge had re-appreciated evidence.

Whether the High Court's Division Bench was justified in setting aside the Single Judge's order and restoring the penalty of removal from service?

Whether an employee's unauthorised absence can be equated to wilful absence when medical justification is discarded without any independent verification from the treating medical professionals?

Whether the penalty of removal from service for an overstay of 99 days satisfies the doctrine of proportionality under administrative law?

Examining the contours of judicial review in disciplinary matters under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the Supreme Court reiterated that while departmental authorities are the primary judges of facts, courts are duty-bound to intervene when conclusions are perverse, arbitrary, or grounded in extraneous surmises.

Unauthorised absence and wilful absence are distinct legal concepts requiring separate assessment.

The Bench clarified that an overstay cannot routinely be treated as deliberate defiance of authority without assessing the underlying circumstances that prevented the employee from resuming duty.

"Absence from duty without prior permission may constitute unauthorised absence; however, unauthorised absence and wilful absence are not necessarily synonymous. The circumstances in which an employee remained absent, the explanation furnished, and the material supporting that explanation must be considered before determining the nature and gravity of the misconduct."

The Court added that an illness or a situation beyond an employee’s control is a vital factor in determining misconduct, even if it does not automatically excuse the entire duration of the absence.

Rejection of medical records cannot rest on superficial suspicion or handwriting similarities.

Scrutinising the enquiry report, the Bench highlighted that the Enquiry Officer disbelieved the medical certificates solely on the ground that the prescriptions and medicine receipts appeared to have been written with the same pen and lacked hospital registration numbers.

The Court noted that the enquiry officer drew inferences of fabrication without undertaking any verification from the treating doctor, the hospital establishment, or the pharmacy.

"Similarity in the writing or ink, without material connecting it to fabrication, could not reasonably sustain the conclusion drawn in the present case. The absence of an indoor or outdoor patient number, and the circumstance that the doctor appeared to have treated the Appellant privately while affixing his official seal to the fitness certificate, could call for clarification. These features did not, by themselves, establish either that no treatment had been received or that the documents were forged."

Consequently, the Court held that the Single Judge had correctly identified that the disciplinary findings rested purely on conjecture rather than substantive legal evidence.

Punishment in uniformed services must satisfy the doctrine of proportionality.

Addressing the quantum of penalty, the Court acknowledged that maintaining high discipline in a sensitive uniformed force like the CRPF is essential, but stressed that the administrative sanction must still align with the gravity of the lapse.

"In the present case, the punishment of removal from service for over-staying the period of 99 days is unduly harsh considering the relevant circumstances. Even after taking into account the earlier periods of overstay and the Appellant’s failure to maintain communication, we are satisfied that the penalty of removal from service, in these particular circumstances, is grossly disproportionate in the facts of this case."

The Court affirmed that where a punishment shocks the conscience of the court, judicial review permits intervention to ensure the penalty is proportionate to the proved infraction.

Allowing the appeal, the Supreme Court set aside the Division Bench judgment, restored the Single Judge's order, and directed the respondents to reinstate the appellant into service with immediate effect, granting him 50% back wages for the period of removal along with all consequential service benefits.

Date of Decision: November 16, 2026

 

Latest Legal News