-
by sayum
17 November 2026 9:07 PM
"In order to enable the Court to safely rely upon the evidence of the investigating officer, it is necessary that the exact words attributed to an accused, as statement made by him, be brought on record and, for this purpose the investigating officer is obliged to depose in his evidence the exact statement and not by merely saying that a discovery panchnama of weapon of offence was drawn..." Supreme Court of India.
NEW DELHI: Emphasizing the strict evidentiary standards required to establish a discovery under Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, the Supreme Court on Monday (November 16, 2026) held that an Investigating Officer must explicitly depose to the exact words uttered by the accused rather than merely marking the disclosure memorandum as an exhibit. A bench comprising Justice Satish Chandra Sharma and Justice Nongmeikapam Kotiswar Singh ruled that the failure of the police officer to narrate the accused's verbatim disclosure in court renders the recovery legally unproved and inadmissible as an incriminating circumstance.
The appellant was convicted by the trial court under Sections 302, 449, 297, and 201 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860, and awarded the death penalty for the double murder of two women in Haryana, which the High Court subsequently commuted to life imprisonment while acquitting his co-accused. The prosecution’s case rested entirely on circumstantial evidence following the hostility of all private witnesses, relying heavily on recoveries of a stick and a gandasi allegedly discovered pursuant to successive police disclosure statements. The appellant approached the Supreme Court challenging his conviction, contending that the alleged recoveries were unproven and legally unsustainable.
Whether a disclosure statement and consequent recovery can be treated as proved under Section 27 of the Evidence Act when the Investigating Officer fails to depose to the exact words uttered by the accused in court?
Whether the recovery of weapons pursuant to disclosure statements constitutes an incriminating circumstantial link when discrepancies exist regarding the nature of the injuries and the timing of discovery?
Examining the evidentiary framework of Section 27 of the Evidence Act, the Supreme Court noted that the provision carves out a narrow exception to the ban on confessions made to police officers under Sections 25 and 26. The bench reiterated the foundational rule laid down in Pulukuri Kottaya v. King-Emperor, emphasizing that Section 27 embraces only the place from which an object is produced and the accused’s distinct knowledge of it, rather than his past usage or confession of the crime.
Investigating Officer is obliged to orally prove the panchnama by reproducing the exact words used by the accused
Reaffirming the procedural threshold established in Ramanand alias Nandlal Bharti v. State of U.P., the apex court underlined that the prosecution cannot establish a valid discovery simply by proving the signatures of witnesses or marking the discovery panchnama as an exhibit. The court stressed that an Investigating Officer must substantively recount the actual statement made by the accused from the witness box to enable the trial court to test its veracity.
The bench reproduced the binding observations from Ramanand, noting that the requirement of law before accepting evidence of discovery is proving the contents of the panchnama through the deposition of the Investigating Officer. The court highlighted that this requirement becomes even more indispensable when independent panch witnesses turn hostile or fail to support the recovery proceedings during the trial.
Applying these benchmarks to the facts, the court found that the Investigating Officers completely failed to narrate the actual disclosure statements in their evidence. The bench observed that the officers merely deposed in a ritualistic manner that the appellant had "suffered disclosure statements" regarding the concealment of the weapons, without bringing on record the specific words used by the accused person.
Exhibiting the memorandum does not amount to legal proof of the statement under Section 27
The court ruled that because the information allegedly furnished by the appellant was never narrated in oral testimony, the disclosure statements were never proven in the manner known to law. The bench observed that the police simply placed the written memoranda on record without oral substantiation of what the accused had stated, which is fatal to the prosecution's reliance on Section 27.
Addressing the evidentiary value of discoveries, the Supreme Court reiterated its ruling in Manoj Kumar Soni v. State of Madhya Pradesh, affirming that disclosure statements per se, unaccompanied by independent supporting links, cannot form the sole foundation of a conviction. A recovery at best proves knowledge of the location of an article, which cannot be converted into an inference of guilt unless unassailably linked to the crime.
The bench also recorded severe skepticism regarding the recovery of a second weapon, the gandasi, which came three days after the appellant's arrest following the post-mortem report that revealed incised wounds instead of blunt force injuries. Noting that the High Court had discarded a similar belated disclosure made by the co-accused, the Supreme Court held that the prosecution could not alter its narrative on weapons to match medical evidence and then seek to validate it through an unproved disclosure.
Allowing the appeals, the Supreme Court set aside the judgments of the High Court and the Trial Court, acquitting the appellant of all charges under Sections 302, 449, 297, and 201 IPC and directing his immediate release. The court held that the disclosure statements were not proved in accordance with Section 27 of the Evidence Act and that the circumstantial chain was entirely broken.
Date of Decision: November 16, 2026