-
by sayum
17 November 2026 9:07 PM
AMARAVATI: Observing that mere prolonged judicial custody and the filing of a chargesheet do not automatically create an entitlement to bail in grave offences involving sexual assault and murder, the Andhra Pradesh High Court dismissed a regular bail petition filed under Sections 480 and 483 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS).
A Single Judge Bench of Justice Dr. Y. Lakshmana Rao on November 11, 2026 held that where the delay in trial is not solely attributable to the prosecution and material witnesses remain unexamined, the societal gravity of heinous crimes under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (POCSO Act) and the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) outweighs the duration of pre-trial detention.
The prosecution alleged that the petitioner gained the confidence of the de-facto complainant's family under the guise of educational assistance and subsequently subjected her 17-year-old daughter to repeated sexual exploitation at multiple premises. During the intervening night of March 23/24, 2026, the petitioner allegedly murdered the minor girl by smothering her at his residence and transported the corpse to another location to screen the offence. Following an investigation that yielded CCTV footage, recoveries, and witness statements, a chargesheet was filed for offences punishable under Sections 103(1) and 64(2)(m) of the BNS, read with Sections 5(j)(iv)(1) and 6 of the POCSO Act.
Whether an accused facing trial for aggravated penetrative sexual assault and murder under the POCSO Act and BNS is entitled to regular bail under Sections 480 and 483 of the BNSS solely on the grounds of prolonged incarceration exceeding 225 days and the completion of investigation?
Whether the constitutional plea of infringement of the right to speedy trial can be successfully invoked to claim bail when the trial schedule was disrupted at the behest of the accused?
Evaluating the statutory scope of bail jurisprudence in heinous offences, the High Court observed that discretionary relief under criminal procedure must be exercised judiciously rather than as a matter of routine course.
Heinous nature of crime and prima facie material outweigh duration of incarceration
The Bench underscored that the victim was aged approximately 17 years and one month at the time of the incident, thereby squarely attracting the rigorous framework of the POCSO Act. Reviewing the chargesheet records, the Court observed that substantial prima facie material, including incriminating CCTV footage depicting the victim accompanying the accused in his vehicle shortly before the occurrence, substantiated the grave accusations.
The Court rejected the argument that incarceration of over 225 days and completion of the probe warranted liberty, emphasizing that mere detention cannot dilute the severity of the charges.
"Merely because the Petitioner continues in judicial custody, it cannot be said that his right to a fair trial stands impaired, particularly when he is represented by learned counsel before the learned Trial Court."
Speedy trial infringements cannot be cited when delay stems from accused's actions
Addressing the petitioner’s reliance on the right to an expeditious trial, the Bench referred to the Supreme Court ruling in X4 v. State of Rajasthan, noting that appellate and revisional courts should ordinarily refrain from disrupting ongoing trials through intermediate bail grants unless the trial is unduly prolonged without any fault of the accused.
The High Court observed that the prosecution had actively initiated steps to conclude proceedings expeditiously, whereas the trial schedule could not be maintained owing to multiple proceedings and as many as six bail petitions instituted by the petitioner before the trial court.
"It is only in the event if the trial gets unduly delayed and that too for no fault on the part of the accused, the Court may be justified in ordering his release on bail on the ground that right of the accused to have a speedy trial has been infringed... Therefore, at this stage, the Petitioner cannot successfully invoke the ground of delay in trial for seeking bail."
Judicial discretion must prioritize societal interest and witness vulnerability in sexual offences
Relying on the authoritative principles settled in Ram Govind Upadhyay v. Sudarshan Singh and Prahlad Singh Bhati v. NCT of Delhi, the Court reiterated that the more heinous the crime, the greater the circumspection required before admitting an accused to bail. It reiterated that at the bail stage, courts examine whether reasonable grounds exist to believe the accused committed an offence punishable with death or life imprisonment, rather than evaluating proof beyond reasonable doubt.
The Court further took note of submissions indicating that attempts were made to pressurize the deceased victim's parents to compromise the case, affirming that the apprehension of tampering with crucial pending witnesses remained substantial.
"Further, several material witnesses are yet to be examined, and this Court is not inclined to rule out the possibility of the prosecution witnesses being influenced if the Petitioner is enlarged on bail at this stage. Accordingly, this Court finds no merit in the present Criminal Petition."
Finding that the petitioner failed to demonstrate any exceptional or special circumstance to warrant the grant of regular bail in light of the severe statutory punishments and compelling circumstantial material, the High Court dismissed the petition.
Date of Decision: November 11, 2026