Once Admitted In Evidence, Admissibility Of Document Cannot Be Questioned Under Section 36 Of Indian Stamp Act: Madras High Court

16 November 2026 3:17 PM

By: sayum


"That section is categorical in its terms that when a document has once been admitted in evidence, such admission cannot be called in question at any stage of the suit or the proceeding on the ground that the instrument had not been duly stamped." Madras High Court clarified that the bar under Section 36 of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899, precludes any challenge to the admissibility of a document once it has been formally admitted into evidence, provided the admission was not inadvertent.

A bench of Mr. Justice K. Rajasekar observed that while Section 36 serves as a significant legal shield, it applies only when a court has judicially determined the document's admissibility upon its tender.

Procedural Context of the Dispute

 The dispute arose from a suit for foreclosure and sale of a mortgaged property, where the plaintiff sought to rely on a mortgage deed (Ex. A6). During trial, the defendant objected to the document’s admissibility on grounds of insufficient stamping and lack of registration. The Trial Court initially marked the document as an exhibit subject to "proof, relevancy, and evidentiary value," leading the defendant to file an application under Order XIII Rule 3 of the CPC to strike the document from the record.

Scope of Section 36 of the Indian Stamp Act

 The primary issue before the court was whether a document marked "subject to objections" could later be excluded from evidence on an application filed by the opposite party. The court was also tasked with determining whether an unstamped and unregistered mortgage deed could be received in evidence for any purpose, including collateral ones, under the Indian Stamp Act and the Registration Act.

Court Explains Section 36 Protections

The court emphasized that Section 36 of the Indian Stamp Act is a penal provision designed to prevent endless litigation over stamp duty once a document is admitted. The bench noted that if a court applies its mind and formally admits a document, the matter is closed for all parties. However, this protection is contingent upon a judicial determination of admissibility at the time the document is tendered.

"Once the Court rightly or wrongly, decides to admit the document in evidence so far the parties are concerned the matter is closed," the court observed, distinguishing this from instances where a document is inadvertently marked without the court’s conscious application of mind.

Distinguishing Objections to Admissibility

The High Court observed that in the present case, the trial court had explicitly recorded the defendant's objections and reserved the issue of "proof and relevancy" for final disposal. Because the document was never unconditionally admitted, the protection of Section 36 did not attach to it. Consequently, the trial court was well within its jurisdiction to entertain a subsequent application to exclude the document.

"The record reveals that the document was not admitted without any objection; rather it was admitted subject to objections," the court noted, clarifying that the bar under Section 36 applies only to documents that have scaled the hurdle of judicial scrutiny regarding their stamp duty at the time of marking.

Impact of Registration and Stamp Duty

Addressing the merits of the document itself, the court held that an unregistered and insufficiently stamped mortgage deed suffers from a fundamental legal infirmity. Relying on settled precedents, the court reiterated that such instruments cannot be admitted in evidence, even for collateral purposes, if they are compulsorily registrable and chargeable with duty.

"As held by the Apex Court in catena of judgments, an unregistered and unstamped document cannot be received in evidence, even for a collateral purpose," the court affirmed. Given these requirements, the High Court found no error in the trial court’s order to reject the exhibit.

The High Court dismissed the Civil Revision Petition, upholding the trial court’s decision to remove the document from the record, thereby reinforcing the strict adherence required by the Indian Stamp Act and the Registration Act regarding the admissibility of property-related instruments.

Date of Decision: 02 September 2026

 

Latest Legal News