-
by sayum
17 November 2026 9:07 PM
"If the cumulative effect of all the abovementioned factors is considered co-jointly, in my considered opinion, the uncorroborated and unsupported testimony of PW-6, a police official, with regard to identity of the appellant was not worth believeable. Rather in view of deposition of DW-1 (the only independent witness of recovery) the testimony of PW-6 was rendered to be unworthy of credit." Setting aside a conviction under Section 15 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 (NDPS Act), the Punjab and Haryana High Court bench of Justice Surya Partap Singh on October 30, 2026, held that the uncorroborated testimony of an interested Investigating Officer is insufficient to prove the identity and conscious possession of an accused who allegedly fled the spot at night, particularly where independent witnesses refute the prosecution's claim.
The prosecution case stemmed from FIR No. 83 dated April 28, 2000, registered at Police Station Nurmahal, Jalandhar, wherein police intercepted a Maruti van carrying 10 bags containing 320 kg of poppy husk. While two occupants were apprehended on the spot, one suspect allegedly fled by jumping out of the rear boot of the vehicle. The trial court convicted the appellant on February 28, 2004, sentencing him to 10 years of rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 1,00,000, which came to be challenged in appeal.
Whether the uncorroborated testimony of the Investigating Officer, an interested witness, is sufficient under Section 15 of the NDPS Act to establish the identity of a suspect who allegedly fled the scene during nighttime?
Whether the complete withholding of spot police witnesses and the independent witness testifying for the defence that no recovery occurred creates fatal infirmities in the prosecution's case?
Scrutinizing the evidentiary record, the High Court observed that the prosecution’s entire identification mechanism rested upon the solitary testimony of Sub-Inspector Kulwant Singh (PW-6), the head of the police interception team. The Court highlighted that the witness, being the Investigating Officer, was an interested witness whose claims required independent corroboration to sustain a conviction.
Uncorroborated testimony of Investigating Officer cannot sustain identification in absence of independent support
The Court underscored that the other recovery witness, Deputy Superintendent of Police Sajjan Singh Cheema (PW-5), reached the scene only after the vehicle had already been stopped and the suspect had purportedly escaped. Consequently, there was no eyewitness corroboration confirming that the appellant was ever travelling inside the vehicle transporting the commercial quantity of poppy husk.
The Bench laid critical emphasis on the role of Jagdish Lal, who was cited by the police as an independent spot witness during the search and seizure. Rather than supporting the police narrative, he was not examined by the prosecution and stepped into the witness box as DW-1 for the defence, deposing that no vehicle was checked and no contraband was seized in his presence.
Independent recovery witness testifying for the defence demolishes the core foundation of the prosecution
The Court observed that the testimony of DW-1 fundamentally dismantled the foundational facts of the case, directly neutralizing the assertions of the Investigating Officer. The Court held that this contradiction rendered the official version unreliable.
Addressing the physical conditions at the time of the alleged escape, the Court noted that the incident took place around 8:00 PM when it was completely dark. The Bench reasoned that the van's headlights would ordinarily be switched on, making it virtually impossible for police officers positioned in front of the vehicle to accurately recognize the face of an individual fleeing through the rear boot.
Darkness and headlights render nighttime identification of fleeing occupant improbable
The Court remarked that the deposition of PW-6 regarding recognizing the appellant under such circumstances was clouded by grave doubt. The Bench faulted the prosecution for withholding other police party members who were present at the barricade, noting that their non-examination remained entirely unexplained.
The Bench also noted serious discrepancies regarding the appellant's identity. While the FIR and recovery memo recorded the fleeing suspect as 'Chhinda s/o Boori', the individual arrested seven months later and brought to trial was 'Surinder Pal @ Chhinda s/o Chain Ram', creating an unresolved anomaly in parentage and identity.
Concluding that the trial court committed an error of judgment by convicting the appellant on conjectures and surmises without credible identification evidence, the High Court allowed the appeal and set aside the impugned judgment of conviction and order on sentence, formally acquitting the appellant of all charges.
Date of Decision: October 30, 2026