Major Prosecutrix Travelling Voluntarily To Public Places Without Raising Alarm Negates Forcible Intercourse Claim: Allahabad High Court Acquits Man Under Sections 366, 376 IPC

17 November 2026 1:36 PM

By: sayum


PRAYAGRAJ: Ruling that an adult prosecutrix travelling freely across public locations without raising an alarm or seeking assistance militates against the prosecution's allegation of forcible rape, the Allahabad High Court on November 16, 2026, set aside the conviction of a man under Sections 366 and 376 of the Indian Penal Code.

Justice Abdul Shahid observed that where the sole testimony of a prosecutrix significantly deviates from her initial statements under Sections 161 and 164 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, such uncorroborated evidence cannot inspire the confidence of the court to sustain a conviction.

The prosecution arose out of an incident allegedly taking place on June 1, 2015, where the victim's father alleged that the appellant had enticed away his daughter, culminating in a Non-Cognizable Report converted into an FIR under Section 366 IPC and a subsequent charge-sheet for rape. Upon being recovered from her own home in May 2016, the victim initially disavowed any abduction or assault before the police and Magistrate, but materially altered her narrative during the trial before the Special POCSO Court in Muzaffarnagar. Aggrieved by the trial court's judgment dated August 24, 2022, which convicted and sentenced him to imprisonment, the appellant approached the High Court in appeal.

Whether an unexplained delay in lodging the police report and continuous omissions to seek help while moving in public places discredits the allegations of kidnapping and rape under Sections 366 and 376 IPC?

Whether the subsequent uncorroborated deposition of a prosecutrix alleging rape can sustain a conviction when it stands contradicted by her own statements recorded under Sections 161 and 164 CrPC alongside medical evidence?

Unexplained Pre-Trial Delay Casts Grave Suspicion On Initial Prosecution Case

The High Court began by examining the initiation of criminal proceedings, noting that the alleged incident occurred on June 1, 2015, whereas the NCR was filed on June 8, 2015, despite the victim's father having knowledge from the very inception. Placing reliance on the Supreme Court ruling in Dilawar Singh v. State of Delhi, the bench reiterated that an unexplained delay in setting the investigative machinery into motion must be viewed with suspicion and often proves fatal to the prosecution.

The bench scrutinized the medical and documentary evidence regarding the prosecutrix's age, highlighting that radiological assessments and executive records placed her age between 20 and 25 years. Noting that she had been married twice previously and settled both separations before community Panchayats, the court held that she was fully aware of the nature and consequences of her actions, leaving no ambiguity regarding her legal status as an adult.

Contradictions In Statements Recorded Under Sections 161 And 164 CrPC Eviscerate Prosecution Theory

The court meticulously analysed the victim's prior statements under Sections 161 and 164 CrPC, wherein she had unequivocally asserted that she deserted her matrimonial home voluntarily due to severe domestic violence. In those statements, she had clarified residing with her cousin in Gannaur, working as a labourer, and emphatically denied that anyone had enticed, abducted, or subjected her to any wrongdoing.

The bench observed that during her medical examination, the victim had specifically stated to the examining doctor that no physical or sexual assault was committed upon her. The medical officer confirmed the total absence of internal or external injuries, noting an old, healed hymen and concluding that there were no clinical findings suggestive of rape.

Sole Deposition Must Inspire Absolute Confidence To Sustain Conviction

Evaluating the victim's court deposition as PW-2, the bench noted that she introduced significant improvements, alleging for the first time that the accused took her through Shamli and Meerut to Haryana and sexually assaulted her for two days. Justice Shahid pointed out glaring mathematical impossibilities in her testimony, including conflicting claims regarding the dates and timelines of her two previous marriages and separations.

Referring to the Supreme Court's decisions in Kuldip Yadav v. State of Bihar and Paramjit Singh Bedi v. State of Punjab, the court emphasized that although conviction on the sole testimony of a prosecutrix is legally permissible, her version must inherently inspire confidence. When the prosecutrix’s testimony lacks truthfulness and is riddled with fundamental discrepancies, convicting the accused purely on that basis remains legally unsustainable.

Free Movement In Public Places Precludes Inference Of Forcible Rape

The High Court laid substantial emphasis on the prosecutrix’s conduct, observing that by her own admission, she travelled to diverse public places without lodging any complaint, raising an alarm, or seeking intervention. Citing the four-judge bench ruling of the Supreme Court in Rajak Mohammad v. State of Himachal Pradesh, the bench noted that when an adult woman moves freely in public without resistance, the possibility of consent cannot be excluded.

Reiterating the settled principle in Uday v. State of Karnataka, the court held that judges must evaluate the surrounding circumstances to determine if consent was genuine or vitiated. Applying the evidentiary standard under Sections 101 and 104 of the Indian Evidence Act as expounded in Paramjeet Singh @ Pamma v. State of Uttarakhand, the High Court ruled that the prosecution had completely failed to discharge its burden of proving guilt beyond reasonable doubt.

In conclusion, the High Court held that the findings arrived at by the trial court were perverse and legally unsustainable in light of the victim's age, medical reports, and previous statements under Sections 161 and 164 CrPC. Setting aside the conviction and sentence passed on August 24, 2022, the court acquitted the appellant of all charges under Sections 366 and 376 IPC and directed his immediate release from prison.

Date of Decision: November 16, 2026

Latest Legal News