IBC | Dissenting Financial Creditors Cannot Be Discharged Through Long-Term Debentures Under Section 30(2)(b); NCLT Cannot Modify Plan & Must Remit To CoC: Supreme Court

17 November 2026 2:35 PM

By: sayum


"A plan which leaves the dissenting financial creditors to be discharged, in substance, through debentures redeemable over a period of six years does not provide for 'payment' within the meaning of Section 30(2)(b) of the Code... Compliance with Section 30(2) of the Code is to be found in the terms of the plan, and not in an undertaking to comply," Supreme Court of India.

NEW DELHI: Holding that payments to dissenting financial creditors under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 must strictly be made in terms of money rather than deferred debentures, the Supreme Court bench of Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe, on November 16, 2026, upheld the NCLAT's decision setting aside the approval of Twinstar Technologies Limited's resolution plan for Videocon Industries Limited and remitting the matter to the Committee of Creditors.

The Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process was initiated against thirteen Videocon group companies, which were subsequently consolidated by the Mumbai bench of the National Company Law Tribunal. Successful Resolution Applicant Twinstar Technologies proposed a resolution plan of Rs. 2,962.02 crores against admitted claims of Rs. 64,838.63 crores, providing for payment to financial creditors partly through non-convertible debentures redeemable over six years, which was approved by the Committee of Creditors by a 95.09 percent majority. The NCLT approved the plan while directing upfront cash payment to dissenting financial creditors, but the NCLAT set aside the approval on statutory appeals filed by dissenting lenders, prompting the appeals before the apex court.

The primary legal issues considered were whether a resolution plan providing payment to dissenting financial creditors through non-convertible debentures satisfies Section 30(2)(b) of the IBC; whether the NCLT can cure such a defect by directing upfront cash payments instead of remitting the plan to the Committee of Creditors; whether the Committee of Creditors becomes functus officio after approving a plan under Section 30(4); and whether foreign oil and gas assets held by downstream subsidiaries can be included in the parent corporate debtor's resolution process under Section 18 of the IBC.

Payment under Section 30(2)(b) means payment in money and excludes deferred debentures

The apex court observed that the mandatory scheme under Section 30(2)(b) read with Regulation 38(1)(b) of the CIRP Regulations requires payment to dissenting financial creditors in money and not by way of deferred securities. Reaffirming its earlier ruling in Jaypee Kensington, the court emphasized that creditors choosing to dissent and exit the corporate debtor cannot be forcefully tied to the revived corporate entity through equities or deferred debentures redeemable over a prolonged timeframe.

A general clause in a resolution plan promising strict adherence to statutory provisions does not cure a deficient payout mechanism. The court held that compliance with Section 30(2) must exist within the substantive terms of the resolution plan itself, noting that an empty undertaking to comply with the law cannot substitute for an express and specific financial allocation.

Adjudicating Authority lacks jurisdiction to rewrite or modify payment structures in resolution plans

Addressing the NCLT's direction compelling upfront cash payment from the initial corpus of Rs. 200 crores to the dissenting financial creditors, the court ruled that such a direction amounted to an impermissible substantive modification of the commercial terms. The bench held that commercial terms and distribution models lie strictly within the province of the Committee of Creditors and cannot be judicially re-engineered by the Adjudicating Authority.

When encountering an incurable statutory deficiency in a resolution plan, the Adjudicating Authority and the Appellate Tribunal are required to send the plan back to the Committee of Creditors rather than unilaterally altering its disbursement structure. The bench highlighted that judicial review under Section 31(1) and Section 61(3) is confined to verifying legal compliance and does not empower tribunals to substitute their own commercial reasoning for that of the creditors.

Committee of Creditors is not functus officio and retains jurisdiction until final implementation

The Supreme Court categorically rejected the contention that the Committee of Creditors becomes functus officio immediately after voting to approve a resolution plan under Section 30(4). The bench noted that the Committee of Creditors acts as a custodian of public trust, primarily comprising public financial institutions managing public funds, and remains in existence throughout the resolution process until the plan is fully implemented or a liquidation order is passed.

Because the NCLT's approval was promptly challenged and stayed under Section 61(3), the approval never attained finality. The court held that the Committee of Creditors was fully competent to revisit its earlier approval and seek remittance of the process, particularly when judicial orders had unsettled the foundation of the plan and exposed severe statutory infractions under Section 30(2)(b).

NCLAT possesses incidental power of remand governed by strict circumspection

Affirming the appellate tribunal's power to remand non-compliant resolution plans, the court observed that an express statutory power carries with it all necessary incidental and ancillary powers. Remand serves as the essential connecting link preventing an immediate and catastrophic push toward liquidation, which the IBC expressly treats as an absolute measure of last resort.

To prevent prolonged delays and asset erosion, the court laid down binding guardrails governing the exercise of remand by the NCLAT. The appellate tribunal must exercise remand sparingly, strictly upon a finding of legal non-compliance under Section 30(2) or other laws under Section 61(3)(i), to restore the institutional balance between the tribunal and the Committee of Creditors, while imposing strict directions to adhere to prescribed statutory timelines.

Subsidiary assets cannot be swept into parent company's CIRP under Section 18

On the second group of appeals concerning the foreign oil and gas assets held across Brazil and Indonesia, the bench held that assets owned by downstream subsidiaries cannot be treated as assets of the holding company. Relying upon settled corporate law and the explicit exclusion contained in Explanation (b) to Section 18 as well as Section 36(4)(d) of the Code, the court reiterated that holding and subsidiary companies maintain distinct legal personalities.

The court noted that the promoter had repeatedly sought to sequester and exclude the foreign assets from VIL's obligations prior to the resolution process and actively participated in separate asset-monetization tracks. Applying the principle that a litigant cannot approbate and reprobate, the Supreme Court held that the promoter was estopped by conduct from belatedly demanding the inclusion of offshore subsidiary assets in the consolidated CIRP of the parent entity.

Dismissing the appeals filed by the Successful Resolution Applicant as well as the promoter, the Supreme Court affirmed the NCLAT's judgment remitting the resolution plan to the Committee of Creditors and confirmed the exclusion of the foreign oil and gas assets from the CIRP of Videocon Industries Limited.

Date of Decision: November 16, 2026

Latest Legal News