Disputed Claims Of Easementary Rights Cannot Be Adjudicated Under Writ Jurisdiction When Alternative Access Exists: Andhra Pradesh High Court

16 November 2026 1:48 PM

By: sayum


"The jurisdiction under Article 226 is primarily intended to examine the legality of governmental or statutory action and is not ordinarily suited to the adjudication of disputed questions relating to title, possession, easementary rights or the physical features of land, particularly where their determination requires an evaluation of oral and documentary evidence, " Andhra Pradesh High Court

AMARAVATI: Emphasizing that summary writ jurisdiction cannot be invoked to resolve contested questions of fact and property easements, the Andhra Pradesh High Court single bench of Justice K. Sreenivasa Reddy on October 8, 2026, dismissed a writ petition challenging the alleged demolition and submergence of a pathway adjoining a public water tank. The Court ruled that where alternative road access is available and the existence, continuous usage, and physical characteristics of an alleged pathway are disputed, a remedy under Article 226 of the Constitution of India cannot lie.

The petitioners approached the High Court claiming ownership over agricultural lands in Jagannadhapuram village, alleging that a pathway across canal poramboke land in R.S. No. 187/2 served as their sole ingress and egress from time immemorial. They sought a writ of mandamus against official respondents and a non-profit foundation for attempting to merge the existing 'Gandhi Cheruvu' tank with adjacent gifted land to expand drinking water storage, alleging that this unlawfully dismantled and submerged their pathway. The respondent authorities refuted the claims, stating that the land was designated as canal poramboke, the bund remained intact under water, and the petitioners possessed alternative motorable access barely half a kilometer away.

Whether disputed easementary rights and contested claims of necessity over a public canal poramboke pathway can be adjudicated under Article 226 of the Constitution of India?

Whether land classified as a canal poramboke and designated as a public water body can be claimed as a private pathway of ingress and egress when alternative access networks exist?

The High Court observed that the primary controversy turned on whether the petitioners had an exclusive right of necessity over the pathway and whether the Gram Panchayat could execute a project to enhance drinking water supply by merging the water bodies. The official respondents demonstrated that the land in R.S. No. 187/2 was classified as canal poramboke and designated as a water body, which cannot be diverted from its intended purpose under prevailing norms.

Public water bodies cannot be converted or diverted for individual access when alternative routes exist.

The Court underscored that the revenue classification precluded the petitioners from demanding that a designated water body serve as their personal passage. "R.S.No.187/2 is classified as canal poramboke and is intended for use as a water body. The petitioners cannot, merely on the basis of their alleged prior use, claim that the said land must continue to be available as a pathway, particularly when its existence and location are disputed and the respondents assert that alternative access is available," the bench recorded.

Substantial alternative access dismantles the plea of an easement of necessity.

Addressing the petitioners' argument of having no other access to their lands, the Court relied on factual submissions showing that the petitioners could approach their holdings through existing roads on the eastern, western, and northern sides covering an approximate distance of half a kilometer. The Court held that this availability of proximate alternative access negated any claim of unmitigated necessity, noting that "in view of the respondents' assertion that the petitioners have alternative access to their lands... through the existing road network on the eastern, western and northern sides, the claim of exclusive necessity pleaded by the petitioners cannot be accepted."

Disputed easementary rights require evaluation of evidence and cannot be decided in writ proceedings.

Examining the boundaries of extraordinary writ jurisdiction, Justice Reddy emphasized that disputed questions concerning title, boundaries, and prescriptive easements cannot be determined solely on affidavits. The Court observed, "The existence of an easementary right, particularly when its location, continuous user, nature and necessity are disputed, requires adjudication on the basis of appropriate oral and documentary evidence. Such competing claims cannot ordinarily be conclusively determined merely on the basis of affidavits in proceedings under Article 226 of the Constitution of India."

Public interest in augmenting village drinking water supply outweighs disputed private convenience.

The bench also distinguished earlier judicial precedents prohibiting the assignment of road poramboke lands, pointing out that the present case did not involve an assignment to a private individual. Instead, private patta land was purchased and gifted to the Gram Panchayat by a philanthropic organization solely to augment the drinking water supply for villagers experiencing severe water scarcity. Finding no established infringement of an enforceable legal right, the Court held that summary interference was unwarranted.

The High Court accordingly dismissed the writ petition and closed all pending applications, holding that disputed questions regarding the existence of the pathway and the claimed easementary rights could not be adjudicated under Article 226 of the Constitution.

Date of Decision: October 8, 2026

 

Latest Legal News