-
by sayum
17 November 2026 9:07 PM
Delhi High Court, in a significant ruling dated September 28, 2026, held that statutory interest on customs duty cannot be computed for the period during which the liability itself remained undetermined due to pending confiscation and adjudication proceedings.
A division bench of Justice Anil Kshetarpal and Justice Shail Jain observed that until an adjudicating authority finally determines the duty and redemption consequences under the Customs Act, 1962, the period cannot be retroactively treated as a "delayed payment" of the subsequently determined liability.
The petitioner, a proprietorship firm, imported goods declared as "Bitumen" in May 2015, which were subsequently seized by customs authorities after being re-classified as "Used Oil." The adjudication proceedings arising from a Show Cause Notice dated September 15, 2015, remained pending for over seven years, despite the petitioner’s repeated requests for an early decision. Upon the final Order-in-Original passed in February 2023, the petitioner was assessed for duty, redemption fines, and penalties, but was simultaneously faced with a substantial interest demand reflected in the Customs EDI System dating back to the initial 2015 filing.
The primary question before the court was whether the petitioner could be held liable for interest under the Customs Act for the period during which the goods remained seized and the adjudication proceedings were pending before the department. The court was also called upon to determine whether the statutory interest liability could be computed from the date of the original Bill of Entry despite the subsequent alteration of the goods' classification and the eventual determination of liability in 2023.
Distinguishing Navayuga Engineering Precedent
The court analyzed the scope of Section 125 of the Customs Act, referencing the Supreme Court's decision in M/s Navayuga Engineering Co. Ltd. v. Union of India. The bench noted that while the owner of confiscated goods is liable to pay duty upon redemption, the assessment and determination of such liability must follow the machinery of Section 28. The court clarified that the statutory interest obligation only crystallizes once the amount has been formally determined following the adjudication process.
"Interest cannot be calculated for a period during which the liability sought to be subjected to interest had itself not been determined."
The bench emphasized that the respondent could not retrospectively treat the liability arising from the 2023 adjudication as having been "outstanding" since 2015. The court observed that the initial 2015 assessment was based on a different classification entirely, and the subsequent seizure rendered the goods unavailable for clearance, thereby making the final determination in 2023 the operative date for the accrual of interest.
Role of Departmental Delay
While the court clarified that it was not holding that departmental delay automatically extinguishes statutory interest, it maintained that interest computation must be logically anchored to the finality of the adjudication order. The court explicitly rejected the respondent’s reliance on the EDI system, stating that the electronic system cannot create a liability not authorized by the statute or validly computed under the Act.
"The Respondent shall not compute interest for the period from 08/09.05.2015 till 28.02.2023 merely on the ground that the original Bill of Entry had been assessed in May, 2015."
The bench underscored that the petitioner had been diligent in seeking adjudication throughout the seven-year delay. Consequently, it set aside the interest computation reflected in the EDI system to the extent that it included the period prior to the February 2023 adjudication order. The court directed the customs authorities to recompute the interest liability, excluding the period of departmental pendency, and to account for all previously paid duties and fines.
The High Court partly allowed the petition, directing the respondent to issue a fresh interest computation within four weeks. The ruling reinforces the principle that statutory interest cannot be levied during periods where the liability is yet to be ascertained, thereby protecting importers from the consequences of prolonged administrative delays in the adjudication process.
Date of Decision: 28 September 2026