Tenancy Rights – Section 5(11)(c) Bombay Rent Act – Claim of Tenancy by Family Member – Plaintiff’s Status as Tenant Rejected – The applicant claimed tenancy rights under the Bombay Rent Act as a family member of the deceased original tenant, Ms. Dinamai Rustomji Master, asserting residence since 1974 – The trial court accepted the claim, but the Appellate Bench...
Constitutional Law – Right to Life – Infringement – Petitioner sought assistance for the installation of electricity at a rented garage space for a commercial venture – Private respondents obstructed the installation in violation of the Executive Magistrate’s order under Section 144(2) Cr.P.C – The Court held that such actions infringed upon the petitioner&rsquo...
Judicial Appointments – Elevation to High Court – Writ petition under Article 32 challenging the process of reconsideration for elevation of two senior-most District and Sessions Judges in Himachal Pradesh High Court – Petitioners argued against the appointment of officers junior to them without reconsideration of their names as directed by the Supreme Court Collegium – Hig...
Indian Succession Act – Probate and Letters of Administration – Will Dispute – Appellants challenged the grant of probate for the Will dated 30th July 1956, executed by deceased Ibrahim in favor of his grandson (Respondent) – The Trial Court granted probate despite the non-production of the original Will – Appellants argued that the Will was surrounded by suspicious c...
Excessive Demand for Final Payment – Validity of Sale Deed Terms – Declaration Rejected - The appellant sought a declaration that VUDA's demand for Rs.533,275.37 was excessive and arbitrary – Held: The sale deed explicitly provided that the price mentioned was tentative, and the appellant agreed to pay any excess amount upon final determination of compensation – The app...
Constitutional Law – Validity of Legislation – Khalsa University (Repeal) Act, 2017 – Challenge to the repeal of Khalsa University established under the 2016 Act – Appellant argued the repeal act was discriminatory, arbitrary, and violated Article 14 of the Constitution – Respondent State of Punjab justified repeal, citing protection of the heritage character of Khals...
Service Law - Social Forestry Workers – Claim for Permanency – Kalelkar Award – Writ Petitions by Social Forestry Division challenging the Industrial Court’s orders granting permanency to daily wage workers under the Kalelkar Award – Petitioners contended that workers were engaged seasonally and not entitled to permanency as no sanctioned posts existed – Held: I...
Civil Law - Derivative Action – Rights of Shareholders – The appellants, minority shareholders, filed a derivative action challenging the sale of a property owned by the company. They sought injunctions and other reliefs on the ground of mismanagement and under-valuation – Held: A shareholder has no direct right over the assets of the company. However, in derivative suits, shareh...
Education Law – Admission Delay – Petitioner, a meritorious student from the Scheduled Caste category, secured a rank of 1455 in JEE (Advanced) 2024 and was allotted a seat in IIT Dhanbad for B.Tech in Electrical Engineering – Due to technical issues, his payment and document upload failed before the portal closed – Despite multiple login attempts, his fee payment was unsuc...
Taxation Law - Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code – Extinguishment of Claims – Section 31 and Section 32A IBC – The appellant sought to extinguish excise duty demands not included in the resolution plan approved during Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) under IBC – Held: Following the resolution plan approved by the NCLT and in the absence of a claim filed by the re...