Civil Law – Cheque Bounce – Suit for Recovery of Money – Plaintiff, a coffee trading company, claimed that the defendant issued a cheque for ₹14,07,456 to clear outstanding dues – Cheque was dishonored due to insufficient funds – Trial Court dismissed the suit, finding that the cheque was issued in favor of the company's chairman in his personal capacity, not th...
Specific Performance – Agreement to Sell – Perversity in Findings – Appeal Allowed – Appellant, Lakha Singh, challenged the concurrent findings of the lower courts denying specific performance of an agreement to sell land and directing recovery of earnest money – The respondent-plaintiff alleged that the appellant-defendant failed to execute the sale deed as per the a...
Public Employment – Reservation Policy – Recruitment for Primary Teachers – Notification for 1423 posts of Primary Teachers was issued on 12.09.2006 – OBC reservation was introduced on 27.12.2006 after the recruitment process had commenced – High Court ruled that OBC reservation could not be applied retrospectively – Held: High Court’s judgment upheld, and...
Civil Procedure – Written Statement – Order 8 Rule 1 of CPC – Revision petition filed challenging the acceptance of a written statement beyond the stipulated 90 days – Plaintiff contended that the trial court erred in allowing the written statement without a formal application for condonation of delay – Held: The court cannot extend time for filing the written stateme...
Civil Law - Coparcenary Property – Transfer of Joint Property by One Coparcener – Void Gift Deed – The plaintiffs sought recovery of possession after their coparcener, without their consent, gifted joint ancestral property to a school – Held: Since the property was not partitioned by metes and bounds, the defendant’s unilateral gift of joint family property without co...
Civil Law - Specific Performance of Contract – Validity of Agreement – The appellant challenged the decree for specific performance of an agreement to sell, claiming the agreement was fraudulent and executed to secure a loan – Held: The plaintiff proved the execution of the agreement to sell, including receipt of earnest money. The appellant’s defence of fraud and forgery w...
Civil Writ - Interpretation of Section 142(1), Maharashtra Prohibition Act – Powers of Collector – The petitioners, liquor license holders, challenged the closure orders under Section 142(1) of the Maharashtra Prohibition Act, which mandated the closure of all liquor shops in the district on Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar Jayanti – Held: The term "any place" in Section 142(1) m...
Auction Sale – Valuation of Property – Maharashtra Cooperative Societies Act, 1960 – Auction Challenged – Auction Upheld – Appellant, Ahmednagar District Central Cooperative Bank Ltd., challenged the auction sale of Mula Sahakari Soot Girni Ltd.’s property, claiming undervaluation and insufficient participation by bidders – High Court dismissed the writ pe...
Education Law – MBBS Admissions – OCI Cardholders' Eligibility – Petitioner, an Overseas Citizen of India (OCI), sought admission under the category reserved for wards of gallantry award recipients – The petitioner was allocated an NRI quota seat but sought admission under the State quota – Held: The petitioner did not fulfil the eligibility requirements under the...
Ryotwari Patta – Non-Service of Notice – Andhra Pradesh Inams Act – Petition Dismissed – Petitioners challenged the grant of Ryotwari Patta to Sri C. Vishwanathaiah on 04.01.2002, arguing that no notice was issued to them or their vendors – Held: For claiming Ryotwari Patta under the Act, petitioners must demonstrate a title flowing from an Inamdar or tenant of an Ina...