Refund of Stamp Duty – Section 49 of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 – Refusal of Refund Upheld - The petitioner sought a refund of Rs. 65,37,500 paid as stamp duty and transfer duty for a sale deed that was refused registration. The High Court held that once the stamp duty has been utilized for a presented document, it cannot be refunded merely because the registration was refused for non-...
Eviction Suit – Judgment on Admission – Order XII Rule 6 of CPC – Admission Must be Clear and Unambiguous – Judgment Set Aside - The appellants challenged the eviction decree based on the alleged admission in a different case regarding the succession of tenancy rights. The Court emphasized that a judgment under Order XII Rule 6 requires an unequivocal and unconditional admi...
Stamp Duty – Imposition of Penalty – The appellant challenged the trial court’s order directing payment of ten times the deficit stamp duty penalty under Section 34 of the Karnataka Stamp Act. The appellant contended that the penalty should not have been imposed at the interlocutory stage and instead argued for the application of Section 37(2), allowing for a determination of pen...
University Regulations – Post-Publication Review – Retrospective Application – Petitioner challenged the suo motu review conducted by the University, which led to the reduction of her CGPA and resulted in her demotion from First Class First to First Class Second – University cited a resolution passed on December 24, 2018, requiring a review of the top three examinees if a p...
Municipal Law – Unauthorized Construction – Regularization of RCC Slab over Public Nallah – The petitioners, residents of Tarangan Housing Complex, challenged the TMC’s regularization of an unauthorized RCC slab and columns over a public Nallah, which obstructed access to the Complex. The High Court found that the regularization was granted despite TMC’s earlier demol...
Environmental Law – Air Pollution – Implementation of Directions – CAQM's Failure to Enforce Orders – The Supreme Court reviewed the compliance report submitted by the CAQM on the enforcement of directions issued regarding stubble burning and air pollution control. Despite the issuance of multiple directions, including one on 10th June 2021 and another on 12th April 202...
Specific Performance – Readiness and Willingness – Plaintiff’s suit for specific performance of an agreement to sell was dismissed by the trial court. The High Court upheld the dismissal, noting the plaintiffs’ failure to demonstrate readiness and willingness to perform their contractual obligations by the stipulated date. The plaintiffs were aware of the pending litigation...
Merit List – Non-operation of Merit List Downwards – Petition Allowed – The petitioners, qualified candidates for Assistant Engineer (Electrical) posts, contended that despite the Supreme Court’s judgment, the Telangana State Power Generation Corporation did not operate the merit list downwards to fill 42 unfilled posts – The Court held that the corporation’s de...
NEET Counseling – Refund of Security Deposit – Procedural Remedy – The petitioner participated in the NEET (UG) counseling for the academic session 2022-23 and deposited a security amount of Rs. 2,00,000/-. Despite not being allocated any institution, the petitioner did not receive the refund – Held: The respondent authorities are directed to decide on the petitioner's ...
Civil Law – Redevelopment Scheme – Dispute Over Rent and Dues – Developer's Obligations – The respondents (tenants) approached the Bombay High Court seeking a writ of mandamus to compel the developers (petitioners) to pay outstanding rent and complete the redevelopment of Chunawala Building as per a scheme sanctioned by the Maharashtra Government. The High Court issued ...