Electricity Supply – Applicable Code – NOC Issuance – Petitioners, developers of various residential colonies, sought release of electricity connections as per the supply code applicable at the time of NOC issuance (2007-08) – Court held that the Supply Code, 2014 enables the distribution licensee to insist the developer fulfill updated requirements – Issuance of NOC ...
Pension – Inclusion of Work Charge Service – Any employee who has rendered service on work charge/adhoc basis is entitled to count the period of such service towards the total length of qualifying service for pensionary benefits – Respondent's rejection of pension claim on grounds of not having 20 years of regular service set aside – Estoppel principle applied as petiti...
Income Tax – Stay Orders – Constitutional Validity – Third Proviso to Section 254(2A) – Appeal challenging the validity of the proviso which prevents extension of stay orders beyond 365 days irrespective of the assessee’s responsibility for delay – Supreme Court held that the proviso violates Article 14 of the Constitution by treating unequals equally – Pr...
Company Law – Winding Up – Non-Payment of Dues – Defence of Defective Material – Appellant claimed huge losses due to defective material supplied by respondent – No documentary evidence provided – Respondent acknowledged defects by granting credit – Company Judge and Division Bench found defence not bonafide – Appeal dismissed [Paras 1-19].
...
Arbitration – Appointment of Arbitrator – Novation of MoU by SHA – Whether the MoU has been superseded by the SHA requires detailed consideration – Section 11 court’s jurisdiction limited to prima facie review – Arbitration clause in MoU cannot be negated without thorough analysis – Appeal allowed, parties referred to arbitration [Paras 1-9].
Scope of S...
Seniority – Fixation by Promotion – Petitioners promoted retrospectively to the post of Food and Supplies Officers from dates of completion of 3 years of experience – Petitioners placed lower than direct recruits in seniority despite earlier retrospective dates – Held, appointments from any source subject to completion of probation – Probation period for direct recrui...
Hindu Undivided Family – Presumption of Tenancy – Mere payment of rent by great grandfather or by the grandfather of the plaintiff raises no presumption that it was a joint Hindu family business. Challenge in the present appeal is to an order passed by the High Court whereby a writ petition filed by plaintiff was allowed holding that the tenant in the premises in question was represent...
Reservation – Ex-servicemen Category – Lineal Descendants – Punjab Recruitment of Ex-servicemen Rules, 1982 – Appellant contended non-inclusion of LDESM candidates in the shortlist for mains examination was against the rules and advertisement terms – Court held Clause 11 of the advertisement clearly states LDESM candidates considered only if no ESM candidates are avai...
Eligibility Criteria – Sports Category – Competitive Examination – The appellant applied for the Punjab State Civil Services Combined Competitive Examination 2020 under the Sports Persons category and received an admit card accordingly – During scrutiny, his sports certificates did not meet the eligibility criteria as per the Punjab Recruitment of Sportsmen (First Amendment...
Promotion Criteria – Rule 13.14(2) of Punjab Police Rules 1934 – Eligibility criteria for promotion to Inspector – Rule 13.14(2) prescribes eight years' approved service for promotion to selection grade of Sub-Inspector, with at least five years in the rank of Sub-Inspector – High Court upheld requirement as neither arbitrary nor discriminatory – Government order ...