Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 - Permanent Disability - The claimant, a five-and-a-half-year-old child at the time of the accident, suffered 100% permanent disability due to multiple severe injuries, including cerebral edema, spinal cord injuries, and paralysis. The MACT awarded compensation of Rs. 900,000, which the High Court enhanced to Rs. 2,320,000. The Supreme Court further considered the adequacy...
Rent and Eviction - Mesne Profits - Termination of Tenancy - After passing the decree of eviction, the tenancy terminates, and from the said date, the landlord is entitled to mesne profits or compensation for being deprived of the use of the premises. The determination of mesne profits should be equivalent to the market rent required to be paid by a person holding over the property.
 ...
Disciplinary Proceedings - Nullity - Time Limit - The High Court held that the disciplinary proceedings were nullity as they were not completed within the time limit prescribed by the Tribunal. The Supreme Court, however, clarified that fixing a time limit by the Tribunal does not equate to a statutory mandate that renders proceedings null and void if not adhered to.
Extension of Time - T...
Service Law – Direct Recruitment – Inter-se merit list – Preparation of inter-se merit list of selected candidates is inevitable even in the absence of an explicit provision in the rule or policy. The recruitment authority cannot place the candidates inter-se in the select list under the rule of thumb or by adopting a methodology inconsistent with the spirit of Articles 14 and 16...
Service Law – Selection Criteria – The Board of Examiners altered the selection criteria by introducing interviews and merit-based assessments not prescribed by the statutory rules. The eligibility and procedure for promotion from Class-IV to Class-III positions, as per the Executive Council’s rules, emphasized seniority and passing departmental tests without mandating interviews...
Court Fees – Suit Valuation – Nature of relief decisive for suit valuation – Market value of property involved in litigation not decisive for suit valuation – Plaintiff entitled to value the relief of injunctions and damages separately – High Court erred in considering market value for determining suit valuation [Paras 1-15].
Injunctions – Sui...
Civil Law – Presumption of Marriage – Long cohabitation between a man and a woman raises a presumption of marriage under Section 114 of the Evidence Act – The High Court erred in denying partition of property based on the legitimacy of the plaintiff – Sufficient evidence of long cohabitation and recognition of the relationship by society supports the presumption of marriage...
Civil Procedure – First Appeal – Scope and Duty of First Appellate Court – Section 96 CPC provides for filing an appeal from a decree passed by a court of original jurisdiction – Order 41 Rule 31 mandates that the judgment of the appellate court must state points for determination, decisions thereon, and reasons for decisions – Appellate court’s failure to compl...
Custody of Minor - Mother's Right – Writ of Habeas Corpus under Article 226 – Section 6 of Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956 – Custody of minor girl child aged less than 5 years – Petitioner-mother sought custody from father and grandparents – Held, mother's love and care indispensable for healthy growth – Grandparents unable to provide equivalen...
NEET-PG Counselling – Conduct of Special Stray Round – Petitioners sought a Special Stray Round of counselling for the remaining 1456 vacant seats after NEET-PG-2021 counselling rounds – Supreme Court held that the admission process must have an endpoint and must adhere to a strict schedule – Emphasized that any deviation could compromise medical education standards and pub...