Service Law – Dismissal from Service – Forged Educational Certificate – Petitioner challenged his dismissal based on alleged submission of a forged transfer certificate to alter date of birth – Acquitted by the criminal court on the same facts – Disciplinary Authority failed to provide evidence of forgery and did not address objections raised by petitioner – App...
Arbitration – Challenge to Award – Interest on Claims – VAT Claims – Challenge under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act against an award allowing claims for unsupplied items and VAT components – Held that the arbitrator acted beyond jurisdiction by granting claims contrary to contractual terms – Clause 15.4 of the tender document precluded any in...
Surplus Land – Permissible Area – Non-utilization – The Court held that the land declared as surplus cannot be utilized by the State until the permissible area and surplus area of the plaintiff have been separated and distinctively identified as per Section 14(1) of the Haryana Ceiling on Land Holdings Act, 1972. The proceedings under the Punjab Security of Land Tenures Act, 1953...
Electricity Regulation – Limitation – Refund of Excess Charges – Petitioner (MSEDCL) challenged CGRF orders directing refund of excess AEC and FAC charged – Contention that claims were barred by limitation – High Court held that the cause of action arose upon MERC’s clarification order and complaint filed within two years was timely – Regulation 6.6 of MER...
Administrative Law – Policy Decision – Relocation of Railway Stalls – Petitioner, an allottee of a catering stall at Dadar Railway Station, challenges multiple orders directing the relocation of her stall – Petitioner argues non-application of mind, adverse impact on livelihood, and violation of hygienic conditions – Court upholds the railway administration’s po...
Landlord and Tenant – Eviction – Arrears of Rent – Petitioner tenant failed to pay rent for over six months and ignored landlord’s notice demanding arrears – Landlord entitled to decree for possession under Section 12(3)(a) of Bombay Rent Act – Tenant's defence of non-receipt of notice and payment to another heir rejected – Notice considered duly serve...
Pre-emption Rights – Tenancy and Co-sharer Claims – Plaintiffs sought to pre-empt a sale based on tenancy claims over the suit land – Defendants claimed superior rights as tenants in possession – Rival pre-emptors, Samey Singh and Partap, also filed suit claiming rights as co-sharers and tenants.
Tenancy Rights – Evidence and Presumptions – Trial co...
Entertainment Duty – Definition and Scope – Petitioner organized APSARA award function, argued it did not fall under “entertainment” as per Maharashtra Entertainments Duty Act – Court held the function included performances and thus fell within definition of “entertainment” [Paras 10-12].
Sponsorship as Payment for Admission – Reliance C...
Recovery of Loan – Jurisdiction of Civil Courts – Entitlement to Debt Relief
*Recovery Suit – Borrowing and Liability – Suit for recovery of Rs. 40,098.90 filed by Syndicate Bank against Venkata Rama Saw Mills & Timber Depot, and its proprietor Sk. Nayab Rasool, with K. Moodava Kotaiah and N. Anjaneyulu as co-obligants – Execution of demand promissory...
Civil Procedure – Recovery on Promissory Notes – Defendant appealed against trial court’s decree in favor of the plaintiff for recovery of sums due on two promissory notes – Defendant claimed notes were forged and plaintiff lacked capacity to lend – Trial court’s judgment upheld, appeal dismissed – Defendant’s plea that her name was misstated as Saro...