Civil Procedure – Rejection of Plaint – Limitation – Order VII Rule 11(d) CPC – Article 59, Limitation Act – Cause of Action and Date of Knowledge – Suit for cancellation of sale deed filed after 25 years – Trial Court rejected plaint as time-barred – Appellate Court held limitation to be mixed question of fact and law and remanded matter for trial &...
Partition – Ancestral Property – Registered Settlement Deed – Plaintiff and defendants 2 to 4 inherited land from their father via registered settlement deed dated 24.09.1977 – Defendants 2 to 4 sold entire 1 acre of land to defendant no.1 in 1998, despite holding only 3/4th share – Held: Sale not binding on plaintiff’s undivided 1/4th share – Plaintiff en...
Transfer of Suits – Patent Infringement vs. Groundless Threats – Section 25 CPC – Earlier suit under Section 106 Patents Act has independent cause of action – Delhi jurisdiction invoked via online purchase and delivery – Substantial overlap of parties, facts and issues – To avoid duplication and conflicting findings, infringement suit in Delhi transferred to Bom...
Service Law – Class IV Appointment – Validity of Appointments Beyond Advertised Vacancies – Rule 12, U.P. Rules – “Reasonable Dimension” of Waiting List – Appellants appointed against Class IV posts were terminated in 2008 on the ground that appointments exceeded notified vacancies – Advertisement of 2000 mentioned 12 vacancies “subject to incr...
Service Law – Medical Practitioners – Retirement Age – Parity Between Allopathy and AYUSH Doctors – Issue arose whether doctors practicing indigenous systems of medicine (AYUSH) are entitled to the same retirement age as allopathic doctors – Division Bench decisions in NDMC v. Dr. Ram Naresh Sharma (2021) 17 SCC 642, State of Gujarat v. Dr. P.A. Bhatt, 2023 SCC OnLine...
Service Law – Writ - Paramilitary Discipline – Proportionality of Punishment – Section 11(1) CRPF Act – Dismissal Quashed – Petitioner, a long-serving constable, failed to report for second guard shift and did not immediately comply when roused – Misconduct held proved, but punishment of removal from service under a charge framed under Section 11(1) (minor misco...
Family Law – Maintenance to Wife and Minor Son – Justified Separation – Wife alleged harassment, extramarital affair, and addiction issues – Husband claimed wife voluntarily deserted him – Family Court accepted wife’s version supported by criminal complaint and lack of evidence of reconciliation from husband – Held: Justified separation established –...
Consolidation Proceedings – Concurrent Findings – Interference by High Court – Limited Scope – Petitioners challenged orders of Consolidation Officer, Settlement Officer of Consolidation, and Deputy Director of Consolidation denying their claim based on a Will – All authorities recorded concurrent findings that Will was suspicious, not proved, and executed under quest...
Civil Writ - Transgender Rights – Indirect horizontality – Omissive discrimination – Reasonable accommodation – Private school recruitment – Second School denied employment after disclosure of gender identity; violation of Arts. 14, 15, 21 and ss. 3, 9 of 2019 Act – First School’s intentional discrimination not proved though grievance redressal deficient &...
Writ Jurisdiction – Maintainability – Civil Suit Pending – Petitioner challenged the review order passed by Collector under Section 15 of the Punjab Land Revenue Act, 1887, concerning mutation of lease deed – Review application was filed after 25 years – Petitioner had already filed a civil suit questioning the legality of the same order dated 26.02.2008 – Held:...