-
by kapil
21 November 2026 3:55 PM
NEW DELHI: Holding that an inordinate and unexplained delay in recording witness statements under Section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (CrPC) completely dismantles the reliability of the "last seen together" doctrine in a case based on circumstantial evidence, the Supreme Court bench comprising Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice Vipul M. Pancholi, on November 18, 2026, set aside the conviction and life sentence of a man accused of strangulating a woman to death under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC).
The prosecution alleged that the appellant, who was reportedly in an illicit relationship with the deceased, murdered her on the night of September 4, 2013, dumped her body in an iron drum at a limestone kiln, and fled with her jewellery. While the Trial Court discarded the testimonies of two "last seen" witnesses due to a 58-day unexplained delay in recording their Section 161 CrPC statements, it nonetheless convicted the appellant under Section 302 IPC solely on the basis of recovery of ornaments under Section 27 of the Evidence Act. The High Court of Karnataka subsequently affirmed the conviction by erroneously reviving the discarded "last seen together" circumstance alongside the alleged recoveries.
Whether an inordinate and unexplained delay of nearly two months by the investigating agency in recording witness statements under Section 161 CrPC renders the circumstance of "last seen together" unreliable and legally unsustainable?
Whether the High Court was justified in reversing the Trial Court's finding that rejected the "last seen" evidence without assigning any cogent reasons addressing the 58-day delay?
Whether the purported recovery of articles belonging to the deceased under Section 27 of the Evidence Act can independently sustain a conviction for murder under Section 302 IPC in the absence of a proven "last seen" theory or evidence establishing that robbery and murder formed part of the same transaction?
Unexplained delay in examining witnesses under Section 161 CrPC destroys the foundation of the last seen circumstance.
The Supreme Court scrutinized the testimonies of Nagappa (PW-13) and Palakshappa (PW-14), who claimed to have seen the appellant in the company of the deceased on the night of September 4, 2013. The bench highlighted that while the incident occurred on September 4, 2013, and the appellant was arrested on September 12, 2013, the statements of these crucial witnesses under Section 161 CrPC were recorded by the investigating officer only on November 1, 2013.
The Court observed that such an inordinate and unexplained delay of nearly two months creates substantial doubt about the veracity of their claims and invites the risk of concoction and afterthought. Reiterating settled law, the bench noted that the last seen doctrine does not independently establish guilt unless corroborated by proximate and unimpeachable material.
High Court erred by reviving discarded evidence without addressing the procedural lacuna.
The bench observed that the Sessions Judge had expressly rejected the last seen theory, recording that "the evidence is not believable to rely on the last seen theory" owing to the unexplained delay of more than one-and-a-half months. The Supreme Court faulted the High Court for summarily relying upon these very testimonies to complete the chain of circumstances without addressing the 58-day hiatus or providing any legal justification for overturning the Trial Court's finding.
The Court held that where the delay in recording Section 161 CrPC statements remains entirely unexplained by the investigating officer, the prosecution cannot establish the last seen circumstance beyond reasonable doubt, and the benefit of such omission must necessarily accrue to the accused.
Failure to prove the deceased was wearing the recovered ornaments at the time of departure.
The Court further examined the prosecution's failure to establish a continuous link between the last seen event and the alleged recovery under Section 27 of the Evidence Act. Neither PW-13 nor PW-14 mentioned in their delayed statements that the deceased was wearing any jewellery when allegedly seen in the appellant's company.
The bench pointed out that while certain relatives testified that the deceased had jewellery on her person when leaving an earlier family function, none of them witnessed her departing in the company of the appellant, thereby failing to establish that the ornaments recovered a week later were in her possession when she was supposedly last seen alive with the accused.
Presumption under Section 114 cannot be extended to murder without proximate corroboration.
Relying on the three-judge bench rulings in Sanwat Khan v. State of Rajasthan and Raj Kumar @ Raju v. State (NCT of Delhi), the Supreme Court held that the unexplained possession of articles belonging to the deceased can only raise a presumption of theft under Illustration (a) to Section 114 of the Evidence Act. In the absence of cogent evidence showing that the murder and robbery formed part of the same transaction, such possession cannot sustain a conviction under Section 302 IPC.
Reiterating the golden rule articulated in Shivaji Sahabrao Bobade v. State of Maharashtra, the Court concluded that the distance between "may be" and "must be" is long and divides conjectures from sure conclusions, holding that the prosecution failed to prove an unbroken chain of circumstantial evidence.
Allowing the appeal, the Supreme Court quashed the judgment and order of conviction under Section 302 IPC passed by the Sessions Court and affirmed by the Karnataka High Court, and directed that the appellant, having been incarcerated for over 13 years, be released forthwith.
Date of Decision: November 18, 2026