-
by kapil
21 November 2026 3:55 PM
CHANDIGARH — Reaffirming that the substantive right of redemption in a usufructuary mortgage remains alive unless extinguished in accordance with law, the Punjab and Haryana High Court held on September 21, 2026, that the non-production of an original mortgage deed does not defeat a suit for redemption where the existence of the mortgage is proven through consistent revenue entries, registered deeds of transfer of mortgagee rights, and the defendants' own categorical admissions of being mortgagees in possession.
Justice Deepak Gupta ruled that a prior order of redemption passed by a revenue court that was subsequently set aside by a civil court solely on the threshold ground of lack of pecuniary jurisdiction cannot operate as a bar or res judicata against a subsequent civil suit for redemption. The High Court stressed that concurrent factual findings establishing the equity of redemption and fixing the redemption amount on the basis of registered transfer deeds cannot be reopened in a second appeal under Section 100 CPC in the absence of perversity.
The litigation originated from a suit instituted by the respondents-plaintiffs seeking redemption of mortgage and possession over agricultural land measuring 42 Kanal 3 Marla situated in Village Dulhepur, District Faridabad. The plaintiffs had purchased the ownership rights through registered sale deeds in March 2014 from the successors of the original mortgagors, thereby stepping into their shoes and acquiring the equity of redemption subject to subsisting usufructuary mortgagee rights. The defendants, who came into possession as successive assignees of mortgagee rights under a registered deed executed in June 2001 for Rs.8,000/-, contested the redemption after an earlier summary order passed by the Assistant Collector was annulled by a civil court for want of pecuniary jurisdiction.
Whether the non-production of the original mortgage deed defeats a suit for redemption when the mortgage is established through revenue records and admissions of the mortgagees.
Whether setting aside an earlier redemption proceeding solely for lack of pecuniary jurisdiction bars a subsequent civil suit for redemption.
Whether the terms, nature, and redemption amount of a mortgage can be legally inferred from successive registered deeds transferring mortgagee rights without raising a substantial question of law under Section 100 CPC.
Addressing the appellants' challenge regarding the non-production of the original mortgage deed, the High Court held that the absence of the foundational instrument is not fatal where primary and secondary documentary evidence conclusively proves the transaction. The Court observed that the courts below had not proceeded in a vacuum or merely on pleadings, but had evaluated Jamabandis reflecting the mortgage since 1967-68, successive registered assignment deeds, and the defendants' unequivocal admissions.
Non-production of original mortgage deed is a question of fact resolved by concurrent evidence.
Justice Gupta emphasized that once the evidentiary chain establishes uninterrupted mortgagee possession, the plea of non-production of the original deed dissolves into a pure question of fact. The Bench held that the appellants were attempting to secure a re-appreciation of evidence under the guise of legal questions.
The Court noted: "The objection regarding non-production of the original mortgage deed essentially relates to the appreciation of evidence. The Courts below have not proceeded on the basis of the pleadings alone. They have considered the Jamabandi for the year 1967-68, the successive deeds transferring the mortgagee rights, the sale deeds in favour of the plaintiffs and, importantly, the defendants' own admission regarding their status as mortgagees."
Substantive equity of redemption remains intact when previous summary proceedings fail on jurisdiction.
Rejecting the plea that the civil suit was barred due to the earlier annulment of the Assistant Collector's order, the High Court underlined that an order vacated purely for want of pecuniary jurisdiction does not amount to an adjudication on merits extinguishing the equity of redemption. The Court maintained that the substantive right to redeem a mortgage is a continuous right that cannot be snuffed out by procedural dismissals.
The Bench highlighted: "The question, therefore, is not whether the plaintiffs had previously approached the competent forum, but whether, after the earlier proceedings came to an end without adjudication extinguishing the right of redemption, the subsisting right of redemption could be enforced by a civil suit. The first appellate Court has answered this question in favour of the plaintiffs by relying upon the settled principle that the right of redemption, so long as it has not been extinguished in accordance with law, continues to subsist."
Usufructuary mortgage without fixed period retains a continuing right of redemption.
The High Court affirmed that in a usufructuary mortgage where no fixed period for redemption has been stipulated, the right of redemption continues to subsist indefinitely until extinguished through statutory foreclosure or a valid judicial decree. The Bench held that determining the mortgage consideration as Rs.8,000/- on the basis of the assignment deed dated June 18, 2001, was a sound factual finding warranting no interference.
The Court further observed: "It is also significant that the defendants' own pleaded position was that they were mortgagees in possession. Thus, the dispute was not one in which the defendants claimed an independent title adverse to the plaintiffs; their substantive defence was founded upon their status as mortgagees. Once the Courts below found, on the basis of the documentary chain and the admissions of the defendants, that such mortgage subsisted and that the plaintiffs had acquired the equity of redemption, the decree for redemption followed as a consequence thereof."
Concurrent factual findings cannot be reopened under Section 100 CPC without demonstrated perversity.
Concluding that the regular second appeal failed to raise any triable legal issue, the High Court reiterated that the jurisdiction under Section 100 CPC cannot be invoked to reassess evidence or upset concurrent findings grounded in documentary evidence and admissions.
The Court concluded: "Learned counsel for the appellants has not been able to point out any finding of the Courts below which can be said to be perverse, nor has any statutory provision or principle of law been shown to have been misapplied in a manner giving rise to a substantial question of law. The challenge, in substance, seeks reappraisal of evidence and interference with concurrent findings of fact."
Finding no perversity or legal infirmity in the concurrent decrees passed by the trial court and the first appellate court, the High Court dismissed the Regular Second Appeal and upheld the decree permitting redemption and delivery of possession upon payment of Rs.8,000/-.
Date of Decision: September 21, 2026