Benefit Of Acquittal Can Be Extended To Non-Appealing Co-Accused If Prosecution Case Is Found To Be Fundamentally Unreliable: Madras High Court Hindu Marriage Act | Petition For Restitution Of Conjugal Rights Serves As A Valid Defence Against Allegations Of Desertion: Kerala High Court Employee Has No Vested Right To Seek Or Retain Additional Charge; Writ Petition Not Maintainable To Challenge Its Withdrawal: Madhya Pradesh High Court Insurance Act | Insurer Cannot Waive Statutory Deadline For Premium Payment Under Bank Guarantee; No Estoppel Against Statute: NCDRC Absence Of Crime Number In Inquest Report & Discrepancy In Sec 157 CrPC Special Report Renders FIR Doubtful: Allahabad High Court MTP Act  | Termination Of Pregnancy Beyond 24 Weeks Permissible If It Involves Risk To Life Or Grave Injury To Mental Health Of The Victim: Gujarat High Court Section 174A IPC | FIR Cannot Be Quashed If Process Server Reports Indicate Failure To Serve At Ordinary Residence: Delhi High Court Issues Guidelines Insolvency Petition | Transferees Of Debtor Cannot Substitute Debtor To Rebut Allegation Of Intent To Defeat Creditors Under Section 6(b) Provincial Insolvency Act: High Court Medical Negligence | Doctor Cannot Be Held Liable For Choosing One Reasonable Course Of Treatment Over Another: Bombay High Court Cruelty | Non-Registration Of FIR Cannot Be Ground To Discredit Testimony Of Wife Seeking Divorce: Jharkhand High Court No Deception At Inception: Calcutta High Court Refuses To Revive Cheating Charges Against Borrower After One-Time Settlement Consumer Protection Act | Doctrine Of 'Caveat Emptor' Subservient To 'Caveat Venditor'; Auctioneer Liable For Sale Of Encumbered Vehicle: State Commission Section 127 CrPC | Past Compromise Not An Eternal Estoppel To Bar Wife From Seeking Enhancement In Maintenance: Orissa High Court States Can Prescribe Higher Qualifications Than UGC Norms, Additional Tests Promote Meritocracy: Punjab & Haryana High Court Writ Jurisdiction Cannot Be Invoked To Cancel Registered Sale Deed Or Adjudicate Title Disputes: Telangana High Court Principal Employer Cannot Abdicate Statutory Liability For Overtime Wages Of Contract Labour Despite Contractual Indemnity Clauses: Jammu & Kashmir High Court Preliminary Inquiry Not Mandatory For Invoking SC/ST Act Provisions If Allegations Disclose Cognizable Offence: Punjab & Haryana High Court Writ Jurisdiction Cannot Be Invoked For Re-valuation Of Structures Once Compensation Dispute Is Adjudicated Under Section 64 RFCTLARR Act: Telangana High Court Revenue Village Naming | Government Must Ensure Names Do Not Reflect Any Person, Caste, Or Religion Under Policy Guidelines: Rajasthan High Court Section 138 NI Act | Complainant Must Prove Proprietorship Of Firm To Establish Status As 'Payee' Or 'Holder In Due Course': Himachal Pradesh High Court

Stepfather can claim maintenance from Stepson - Calcutta HC Answers

07 May 2024 2:49 AM

By: Admin


The Calcutta High Court held on Tuesday that a stepson cannot dispute his duty to support his stepfather provided he performs the same duties as the biological father.

The court of Justice Kausik Chanda also stated that a biological mother who has entered a second marriage has the legal right to demand support from her son at any time. Sunil Debsharma, the petitioner in this case, lost his father when he was a little child. Fuldi Debsharma, his mother, wed Thelu Debsharma.

Thelu had one son and two daughters from his first marriage, and he was also a widower. After getting married in 2010, Sunil and his wife began to live apart. Their two daughters were.

Under Section 125 of the C.R.P.C., Thelu and Fuldi jointly filed an application for maintenance against Sunil. The Magistrate in the Court below authorised Sunil to pay Thelu and Fuldi a monthly maintenance payment of Rs. 2,500 each.

While this revisional application was still pending, Sunil's wife suffered burn wounds and passed away suddenly. Invoking Thelu and Fuldi, the father-in-law of Sunil filed an F.I.R. under Sections 498A/326/307/34 of the IPC.

  1. If a stepfather has a claim to support from his stepson?
  2. Whether a mother who marries again has a right to maintenance from her first husband's son?

The High Court ruled that "a stepson cannot dispute his duty to maintain him when a stepfather fulfils the same tasks as the biological father. For the same reason, a second-married biological mother has the legal right to demand child support from her son. Without mentioning his own children, it cannot be stated that Thelu cannot demand maintenance from his stepson given the factual context of this case.

The bench granted the petition in light of the aforementioned.

Sunil Debsharma

VS

The State of West Bengal and Others

Download Judgment

[gview file="http://lawyer-e-news.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/sunil.pdf"]

Latest Legal News