-
by kapil
21 November 2026 3:55 PM
"Consequently, the appellants cannot derive the full benefit of the alleged contradictions merely by demonstrating that particular deposition made by the witnesses were absent from Ex.PW-1/A and Ex. PW-2/A, when the prosecution case is that the necessary details were subsequently recorded in the supplementary statements recorded during investigation." Delhi High Court has held that an accused cannot seek the benefit of alleged contradictions or omissions under Section 162 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (CrPC) merely by demonstrating that certain details were absent in the witness's initial inquest statement before a Sub-Divisional Magistrate (SDM), where the defence selectively failed to confront the witness with their supplementary statements recorded under Section 161 CrPC.
A Division Bench comprising Justice Navin Chawla and Justice Ravinder Dudeja also ruled that the engagement of a scribe by an Investigating Officer to write the case diary does not violate Section 172(1) CrPC or taint the probe in the absence of demonstrated prejudice.
The judgment arose from an appeal challenging the conviction and life imprisonment imposed on a husband and his mother under Sections 304-B and 498-A read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC). The deceased had died by hanging within four and a half months of her marriage following persistent harassment and unfulfilled dowry demands for a motorcycle, cash, clothes, and residential renovation funds.
The court was called upon to determine whether omissions in the initial statement recorded before the SDM amount to contradictions vitiating witness credibility when supplementary statements were not put to the witness. The Bench also considered whether the recording of the case diary by private scribes vitiates the fairness of the investigation, and whether the statutory presumption under Section 113-B of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 was properly invoked under Section 304-B IPC.
Selective confrontation of previous statements bars claim of contradiction under Section 162 CrPC
Examining the defence plea of material improvements, the Bench noted that the appellants selectively confronted the father and brother of the deceased only with their very first statements recorded by the SDM, while consciously refraining from confronting them with their subsequent statements recorded by the police under Section 161 CrPC. The Court underscored that while statements recorded during investigation are not substantive evidence, they can be utilized for contradiction under Section 145 of the Indian Evidence Act only in the strict manner prescribed by law.
The Court held that the defence cannot establish fatal omissions by cherry-picking records, noting that the registration of an FIR or an initial SDM statement merely sets the criminal law into motion rather than concluding the investigation.
Omission in initial statement explained by trauma and grief of victim's family
Addressing why the initial statements before the SDM were general and lacked granular particulars, the High Court observed that close family members were in a state of profound shock and grief on the day of the suicide, having rushed to the matrimonial home and hospital.
The Bench observed: "One can duly understand the shock, pain and grief in which the family may have been, upon getting the tragic news of the death of their daughter. It would be futile to expect that in such state of mind, the close relatives would be able to furnish the meticulous details of all what happened with the victim during her short-lived marital life. Hence, the absence of specific instances of cruelty on account of dowry demand in the very first statements recorded by the SDM on the day of death of the victim cannot be given much importance."
Section 172 CrPC does not mandate case diary to be in IO's personal handwriting
Rejecting the argument that the investigation was tainted because the Investigating Officer had three private individuals write the case diary, the Bench analyzed Section 172(1) CrPC and held that taking the assistance of a scribe does not run contrary to any statutory embargo.
The Court held: "The law does not mandate that the case diary must necessarily be handwritten personally by the Investigating Officer. No material has been brought on record to demonstrate that the engagement of a scribe, by itself, has caused any prejudice to the appellants or has otherwise affected the fairness of the investigation. Accordingly, the mere fact that a scribe was engaged for writing the case diary, in the absence of any specific statutory bar or demonstrated prejudice, cannot by itself be treated as a circumstance casting doubt upon the investigation."
Cruelty within four months satisfies 'soon before death' requirement under Section 304-B IPC
The Bench emphasized that the deceased died an unnatural death within four and a half months of marriage, during which there was a continuous course of conduct involving dowry harassment, establishing a live link and proximity to the death as required by Section 304-B IPC.
The Court observed: "To subject a woman to sustained cruelty and harassment on account of dowry demands, to the extent that she is driven to take the extreme step of ending her life, represents a grave form of human suffering and cannot be treated as a mere domestic discord. Marriage, particularly for a woman entering a new family, carries profound social and emotional significance, and the transformation of that sacrosanct relationship into a transaction governed by demands for money, articles and material considerations strikes at the very foundation of the institution of marriage."
Finding that the appellants failed to rebut the statutory presumption under Section 113-B of the Indian Evidence Act, the High Court upheld the conviction and sentence under Sections 304-B and 498-A read with Section 34 IPC, dismissed the appeal, and directed the surviving appellants to surrender within two weeks.
Date of Decision: October 28, 2026