Recovery Under Section 27 Evidence Act Cannot Solely Sustain Murder Conviction Under Section 302 IPC Without Proof That Robbery & Homicide Were Part Of Same Transaction: Supreme Court

20 November 2026 1:00 PM

By: kapil


"Therefore, in the present case, in the absence of cogent evidence showing that the robbery/theft and murder formed part of the same transaction, we are of the view that such recovery, by itself, cannot be stretched to infer guilt of the appellant for murder under Section 302 IPC, " Supreme Court.

NEW DELHI: The Supreme Court on Wednesday observed that the unexplained recovery of ornaments under Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 cannot by itself be stretched to infer guilt for murder under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 in the absence of cogent proof that the robbery and homicide formed integral parts of the same transaction. A Bench comprising Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice Vipul M. Pancholi acquitted an appellant who had served over 13 years of incarceration, holding that the presumption under Section 114, Illustration (a) of the Evidence Act extends only to theft or receipt of stolen property and cannot mechanically establish culpability for a capital offence.

The prosecution alleged that the appellant harboured suspicion regarding the character of the deceased, with whom he shared an illicit relationship, and murdered her by ligature strangulation on the night of September 4, 2013, before concealing her body in an iron drum at a lime kiln and taking her ornaments. The Trial Court acquitted the appellant under Section 201 IPC and discarded the "last seen" testimonies due to an unexplained two-month delay, but convicted him under Section 302 IPC solely on the premise of the recovery of ornaments under Section 27 of the Evidence Act. The High Court of Karnataka subsequently affirmed the conviction and life imprisonment, which came under challenge before the top court.

Whether the unexplained recovery of articles belonging to the deceased under Section 27 of the Evidence Act can independently sustain a conviction for murder under Section 302 IPC without proof that the theft and murder were parts of the same transaction?

Whether an unexplained and inordinate delay of nearly two months in recording statements under Section 161 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 fatally discredits testimonies relied upon under the "last seen together" theory?

Whether general knowledge among relatives regarding an illicit relationship satisfies the requirement of establishing motive in a case resting entirely on circumstantial evidence?

Examining the chain of circumstantial evidence under the five golden principles enunciated in Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v. State of Maharashtra, the Bench underscored that in cases based purely on circumstantial evidence, motive constitutes a crucial link. The Court observed that both the Trial Court and the High Court fell into error by treating the general knowledge of an illicit relationship as proof of motive to commit murder.

Motive cannot be founded on vague conjectures in the absence of proven animosity

The Bench observed that none of the family members had personal knowledge of the illicit relationship or testified that the appellant suspected the deceased of having relations with another person. The Court noted that "none of the prosecution witnesses testified that the appellant harboured suspicion that the deceased was involved with another man or that any quarrel had ever taken place between them on that account," concluding that the alleged motive was reduced to mere conjecture.

Turning to the "last seen together" theory, the Supreme Court held that the High Court committed a manifest error in reversing the Trial Court's rejection of the testimonies without assigning any reasons for brushing aside the 58-day delay. The Bench reiterated that the circumstance of last seen together does not independently point to guilt without proximate and independent corroborative material linking the accused to the crime.

Unexplained two-month delay in recording Section 161 CrPC statements destroys credibility of last seen theory

The Court pointed out that while the incident occurred on September 4, 2013 and the appellant was arrested on September 12, 2013, the statements of the alleged "last seen" witnesses were recorded only on November 1, 2013. The Bench affirmed the Trial Court's finding that "the evidence is not believable to rely on the last seen theory," holding that where the investigating agency offers no explanation for such inordinate delay, the circumstance cannot be treated as conclusively proved.

The Bench also highlighted serious discrepancies in the narrative surrounding the discovery of the dead body inside a lime drum, observing that the anonymous informant who alerted the complainant was never traced or examined. Furthermore, the Court noted that neither the inquest report nor the post-mortem report disclosed any stains or traces of limestone on the clothing or person of the deceased, casting reasonable doubt on the prosecution version.

Recovery under Section 27 Evidence Act rendered doubtful due to procedural infirmities and interested panch witnesses

Scrutinizing the recovery of ornaments from the appellant's residence, the Court held that the statutory prerequisites under Section 27 of the Evidence Act were thoroughly compromised. The independent panch witness was not examined, while the testifying panch admitted that the mahazar was dictated entirely by the police inspector and that he was unaware of the door number or ownership of the house searched.

The Bench took serious note of the fact that the second witness, a goldsmith and appraiser, admitted in cross-examination that he was a routine police witness who did not even carry a weighing scale during the seizure. The Court observed that the prosecution failed to explain how his signature appeared on the seizure mahazar when it had been struck out from the spot mahazar, and that the timeline was contradicted by witness admissions that police had displayed the ornaments a day after the incident.

Presumption under Section 114 Illustration (a) restricted to theft and cannot be stretched to infer murder

Relying on the three-judge bench decision in Sanwat Khan v. State of Rajasthan and reaffirmed in Raj Kumar @ Raju v. State (NCT of Delhi), the Supreme Court ruled that unexplained possession of stolen articles enables only a limited statutory presumption regarding theft or receipt of stolen property. The Bench emphasized that such possession cannot infer guilt for murder unless the prosecution conclusively establishes that robbery and murder were integral components of a single transaction.

The Court observed that no charge was ever framed against the appellant under Section 379, 392, or 404 of the IPC for theft or dishonest misappropriation, and the prosecution had advanced personal animosity rather than gain as the sole motive. Recalling the landmark dictum in Shivaji Sahabrao Bobade v. State of Maharashtra, the Bench reiterated that the mental distance between "may be" and "must be" is long and divides vague conjectures from sure conclusions.

The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, quashed the conviction under Section 302 IPC, and set aside the sentence of life imprisonment affirmed by the High Court of Karnataka. Maintaining the Trial Court's acquittal under Section 201 IPC, the Court directed that the appellant be released forthwith from custody, having suffered over 13 years of imprisonment, unless required in any other case.

Date of Decision: November 18, 2026

Latest Legal News